Neurophysics Group, Department of Neurology, Campus Benjamin Franklin, Charite-University Medicine Berlin, Berlin, Germany.
Clin Neurophysiol. 2012 Oct;123(10):2064-73. doi: 10.1016/j.clinph.2012.03.013. Epub 2012 May 24.
Median nerve somatosensory evoked potentials (SEP) contain a brief oscillatory wavelet burst at about 600 Hz (σ-burst) superimposed on the initial cortical component (N20). While invasive single-cell recordings suggested that this burst is generated by increased neuronal spiking activity in area 3b, recent non-invasive scalp recordings could not reveal concomitant single-trial added-activity, suggesting that the SEP burst might instead be generated by phase-reset of ongoing high-frequency EEG. Here, a statistical model and exemplary data are presented reconciling these seemingly contradictory results.
A statistical model defined the conditions required to detect added-activity in a set of single-trial SEP. Its predictions were tested by analyzing human single-trial scalp SEP recorded with custom-made low-noise amplifiers.
The noise level in previous studies did not allow to detect single-trial added-activity in the period concomitant with the trial-averaged σ-burst. In contrast, optimized low-noise recordings do reveal added-activity in a set of single-trials.
The experimental noise level is the decisive factor determining the detectability of added-activity in single-trials. A low-noise experiment provided direct evidence that the SEP σ-burst is at least partly generated by added-activity matching earlier invasive single-cell recordings.
Quantitative criteria are provided for the feasibility of single-trial detectability of band-limited added-activity.
正中神经体感诱发电位(SEP)在初始皮质成分(N20)上叠加有一个约 600 Hz 的短暂振荡子波突发(σ-突发)。虽然侵入性单细胞记录表明该突发是由 3b 区神经元放电活动增加产生的,但最近的非侵入性头皮记录未能揭示伴随的单次试验附加活动,表明 SEP 突发可能是由正在进行的高频 EEG 的相位重置产生的。在这里,提出了一个统计模型和示例数据,调和了这些看似矛盾的结果。
一个统计模型定义了在一组单试 SEP 中检测附加活动所需的条件。通过分析使用定制低噪声放大器记录的人类单试头皮 SEP,测试了其预测。
以前的研究中的噪声水平不允许在与试验平均 σ-突发同时的时期检测单试附加活动。相比之下,优化的低噪声记录确实在一组单试中揭示了附加活动。
实验噪声水平是决定单试中附加活动可检测性的决定性因素。低噪声实验提供了直接证据,表明 SEP σ-突发至少部分是由与早期侵入性单细胞记录匹配的附加活动产生的。
为带限附加活动的单次试验可检测性提供了定量标准。