Faculty of Health and Social Care Sciences, Kingston University and St George's University of London, Kingston Hill, Kingston upon Thames, KT2 7LB, United Kingdom.
Nurse Educ Today. 2013 May;33(5):465-9. doi: 10.1016/j.nedt.2012.04.023. Epub 2012 May 24.
Whilst an individual's cognitive skills are essential for academic progress, the possession of non-cognitive skills, such as empathy and ethical judgement are attributes required and valued in those applying to join healthcare programmes and by the profession itself. Doubts have been expressed, however, whether final selection using traditional interviewing methods serve adequately to reveal these key competencies. Kingston University and St George's University of London, therefore, have employed the Multiple-Mini-Interview (MMI) system for those applying to their BSc Nursing Programme. The MMI comprises a series of interview 'stations' where candidates respond to scenarios and are assessed on their display of required skills/competences. 890 candidates and 82 interviewers completed a short questionnaire to gauge their reaction to the concept. There were positive responses from candidates with 65% replying that it was "a better experience" compared with traditional interviews. Unsolicited comment was generally found to refer to restrictions on opportunities to express enthusiasm for nursing. Interviewers likewise responded positively with 71% noting "a better experience." Unsolicited feedback indicated that some would have preferred to have had greater opportunity to discuss nursing issues, with their interviewees. It has been agreed that the MMI system of interviewing will be retained and further work will include the tracking of students through and into the workplace.
虽然个人的认知技能对于学业进步至关重要,但同理心和道德判断等非认知技能也是申请医疗保健项目的人以及该行业本身所需要和重视的特质。然而,有人质疑传统的面试方法是否足以充分揭示这些关键能力。因此,金斯顿大学和伦敦圣乔治大学为申请其护理学士课程的学生采用了多模式面试(MMI)系统。MMI 由一系列面试“站点”组成,候选人需要对场景做出回应,并根据他们展示的所需技能/能力进行评估。890 名候选人及 82 名面试官完成了一份简短的问卷,以衡量他们对该概念的反应。候选人的反馈大多是积极的,65%的人表示与传统面试相比,这是“更好的体验”。非征求意见的评论通常是指对表达对护理热情的机会的限制。面试官的反应也很积极,71%的人表示“体验更好”。非征求意见的反馈表明,一些面试官希望有更多机会与他们的面试者讨论护理问题。已达成共识,将保留 MMI 面试系统,并将进一步跟踪学生的学习和工作情况。