Department of Surgery, University of Washington, Seattle, WA, USA.
Trop Med Int Health. 2012 Jul;17(7):808-19. doi: 10.1111/j.1365-3156.2012.03014.x. Epub 2012 May 30.
To review the current training opportunities for ultrasound use for health workers practising in low- and middle-income countries (LMICs).
A PubMed search using terms ultrasound, sonography, echocardiography, developing country/countries, developing world, low resource settings, low income country/countries, training and education was conducted. Articles from 2000 to 2011 that included data on ultrasonography training were eligible for inclusion.
This review shows that most ultrasound scans are performed by generalist and obstetric physicians and even non-medical personnel with little to no formal training in ultrasonography. The spectrum of ultrasonography training described spanned from no formal training to formal certification and residency programmes. All courses included some component of didactics and hands-on training. Follow-up of trainee skills ranged from none, to telemedicine case review, to formal re-evaluations and intensive refresher courses. Ultrasonographic training in LMICs often does not meet the WHO criteria such as the number of scans under supervision and length of training programme recommended by WHO. Nevertheless, some programmes manage to have excellent outcomes with regard to diagnostic accuracy and retention of knowledge by trained personnel.
Regulation and quality control of training in ultrasound skills for those working in LMICs can be improved. Research on effective training and follow-up should be encouraged.
回顾目前在中低收入国家(LMICs)工作的卫生工作者使用超声的培训机会。
使用术语“超声、超声检查、超声心动图、发展中国家/国家、发展中世界、低资源环境、低收入国家/国家、培训和教育”在 PubMed 上进行了搜索。合格的文章包括 2000 年至 2011 年间的超声培训数据。
本综述表明,大多数超声扫描由全科医生和妇产科医生进行,甚至由未经正式超声培训的非医务人员进行。描述的超声培训范围从没有正式培训到正式认证和住院医师培训计划。所有课程都包括一些理论教学和实践培训。对学员技能的后续跟踪从无到有,包括远程医疗病例审查、正式重新评估和强化复习课程。中低收入国家的超声培训通常不符合世界卫生组织的标准,例如监督下的扫描次数和世界卫生组织推荐的培训计划长度。然而,一些项目在诊断准确性和培训人员知识的保留方面取得了出色的成果。
可以改进在 LMICs 工作的人员的超声技能培训的监管和质量控制。应鼓励研究有效的培训和后续措施。