Shrestha Anmol P, Blank Wolfgang, Blank Ursula H, Horn Rudolf, Morf Susane, Shrestha Sanu K, Shrestha Shailesh P, Basnet Samjhana, Dongol Anjana, Kumar Dangal Raj, Shrestha Roshana
Department of General Practice and Emergency Medicine, Dhulikhel Hospital, Kathmandu University School of Medical Sciences Dhulikhel NPL.
University of Tübingen, German societies of ultrasound in Medicine (DEGUM) Tübingen, DEU.
POCUS J. 2024 Nov 15;9(2):133-142. doi: 10.24908/pocus.v9i2.17724. eCollection 2024.
Emergency Medicine Point of Care Ultrasound (EM-POCUS) is a diagnostic bedside tool for quick and accurate clinical decision-making. Comprehensive training in POCUS is a mandatory part of EM training in developed countries. In Nepal, we need to build an educational curriculum based on the local medical system, available resources, and educational environment. We used the modified Delphi method to develop a EM-POCUS curriculum. We formed an EM-POCUS core working group based on expertise in key identified areas. The core working group developed criteria for expert panelist selection and synthesized the data for panelists after each Delphi round. We recruited 46 expert panelists to participate in a series of electronic surveys. The literature review and the results of the first Delphi round identified a set of competencies. Quantitative methodology was performed for subsequent surveys. Data analysis of the frequency, percentage, median, and interquartile range of the 9-point Likert scale was performed. We deemed a minimum threshold of 80% agreement to retain items across Delphi rounds. The result of every round was disseminated before subsequent rounds for the expert panelists to review responses in light of the group's response. : We identified 10 specific global competency categories and 132 objectives (Round 1, response rate 85%). Rounds 2 and 3 (response rates 78% and 81% respectively) developed consensus on 45 core objectives (34%). The list of EM-POCUS competencies with the median (IQR) was finalized. This expert, consensus-generated EM-POCUS curriculum provides detailed guidance for EM-POCUS education and applications in clinical practice in Nepal.
急诊医学床旁超声(EM-POCUS)是一种用于快速准确临床决策的诊断床边工具。在发达国家,POCUS的全面培训是急诊医学培训的必修部分。在尼泊尔,我们需要根据当地医疗系统、可用资源和教育环境构建一门教育课程。我们采用改良的德尔菲法来制定EM-POCUS课程。我们根据关键确定领域的专业知识组建了一个EM-POCUS核心工作组。核心工作组制定了专家小组成员的选拔标准,并在每轮德尔菲法之后汇总小组成员的数据。我们招募了46名专家小组成员参与一系列电子调查。文献综述和第一轮德尔菲法的结果确定了一组能力。后续调查采用定量方法。对9点李克特量表的频率、百分比、中位数和四分位间距进行了数据分析。我们认为各轮德尔菲法中保留项目的最低共识阈值为80%。每轮结果在后续轮次之前公布,以便专家小组成员根据小组的回答审查自己的回答。我们确定了10个特定的全球能力类别和132个目标(第一轮,回复率85%)。第二轮和第三轮(回复率分别为78%和81%)就45个核心目标(34%)达成了共识。最终确定了具有中位数(四分位间距)的EM-POCUS能力清单。这一由专家达成共识产生的EM-POCUS课程为尼泊尔临床实践中的EM-POCUS教育和应用提供了详细指导。