Mommaerts J L, Devroey Dirk
Department of General Practice, Faculty of Medicine, Free University of Brussels, Brussels, Belgium.
Perspect Biol Med. 2012 Winter;55(1):43-58. doi: 10.1353/pbm.2012.0005.
The placebo effect is very well known, being replicated in many scientific studies. At the same time, its exact mechanisms still remain unknown. Quite a few hypothetical explanations for the placebo effect have been suggested, including faith, belief, hope, classical conditioning, conscious/subconscious expectation, endorphins, and the meaning response. This article argues that all these explanations may boil down to autosuggestion, in the sense of "communication with the subconscious." An important implication of this is that the placebo effect can in principle be used effectively without the placebo itself, through a direct use of autosuggestion. The benefits of such a strategy are clear: fewer side effects from medications, huge cost savings, no deception of patients, relief of burden on the physician's time, and healing in domains where medication or other therapies are problematic.
安慰剂效应广为人知,在许多科学研究中都得到了验证。与此同时,其确切机制仍然不明。针对安慰剂效应,人们提出了不少假设性解释,包括信念、信仰、希望、经典条件作用、有意识/潜意识期望、内啡肽以及意义反应。本文认为,所有这些解释归根结底可能都可归结为自我暗示,即“与潜意识的沟通”。这一点的一个重要含义是,原则上可以通过直接运用自我暗示,在不使用安慰剂本身的情况下有效地利用安慰剂效应。这种策略的好处显而易见:药物副作用更少、大幅节省成本、不欺骗患者、减轻医生的时间负担,以及在药物或其他疗法存在问题的领域实现治愈。