Department of Clinical Epidemiology and Biostatistics, McMaster University, Hamilton, Ontario.
Blood. 2012 Jul 26;120(4):720-7. doi: 10.1182/blood-2012-03-378927. Epub 2012 Jun 12.
The development of alloantibodies or inhibitors is the most serious complication a patient with severe hemophilia can experience from treatment with clotting factor concentrates. Although common in previously untreated patients, inhibitor development is rare in multiply exposed, well-tolerized patients. There has been a nonevidence-based reluctance to change concentrate because of a perceived greater inhibitor risk after the switch, even though most patients are now likely to be using a concentrate on which they did not begin. Inhibitors in previously treated patients are observed in approximately 2 per 1000 patient/years, which makes it difficult to study and compare rates among different products. Because the baseline inhibitor risk in previously treated patients may vary over time, it is important to compare the risk in patients switching to a new product with that in a parallel control group of nonswitching patients or within a case-controlled study. The study designs imposed by regulators are suboptimal in detecting immunogenicity signals. The issue of immunogenicity of new products is likely to gain more relevance in the near future, with a call for effective postmarketing surveillance studies for all of the new engineered factor VIII concentrates with prolonged half-lives that are likely to enter clinical practice.
同种抗体或抑制剂的产生是严重血友病患者在接受凝血因子浓缩物治疗时可能经历的最严重并发症。尽管在未接受治疗的患者中较为常见,但在多次暴露且耐受良好的患者中,抑制剂的产生较为罕见。由于担心在转换后会出现更大的抑制剂风险,人们一直不愿意基于无证据的理由更换浓缩物,尽管现在大多数患者可能正在使用他们之前未开始使用的浓缩物。在先前接受治疗的患者中,观察到大约每 1000 名患者/年有 2 名出现抑制剂,这使得难以研究和比较不同产品之间的发生率。由于先前接受治疗的患者的基础抑制剂风险可能随时间而变化,因此重要的是将转换为新产品的患者的风险与不转换的平行对照组患者或病例对照研究中的风险进行比较。监管机构施加的研究设计在检测免疫原性信号方面并不理想。随着可能进入临床实践的具有延长半衰期的新型工程化因子 VIII 浓缩物的上市后监测研究的呼吁,新产品的免疫原性问题可能在不久的将来变得更加重要。