Hawkins M M, Kingston J E, Kinnier Wilson L M
Department of Paediatrics, University of Oxford.
Arch Dis Child. 1990 Dec;65(12):1356-63. doi: 10.1136/adc.65.12.1356.
An investigation of 749 deaths occurring among 4082 patients surviving at least five years after the diagnosis of childhood cancer in Britain before 1971 has been undertaken. Of the 738 with sufficient information the numbers of deaths attributable to the following causes were: recurrent tumour, 550 (74%), a second primary tumour, 61 (8%), a medical condition related to treatment of the tumour, 49 (7%), an traumatic death unrelated to the tumour or its treatment, 34 (5%), finally, any other cause unrelated to the tumour or its treatment, 44 (6%). Less than 10% of five year survivors of non-Hodgkin lymphomas, neuroblastoma, retinoblastoma, Wilms' tumour, or a soft tissue sarcoma died of recurrent tumour during the next 15 years, while more than 25% of five year survivors of Hodgkin's disease, ependymoma, medulloblastoma, and Ewing's tumour died of recurrent tumour during the corresponding period. Almost 50% of five year survivors of acute lymphoblastic leukaemia died of recurrent disease during the corresponding 15 years, a large proportion of deaths being due to central nervous system relapse in an era before central nervous system prophylaxis was routinely given. Comparison of the mortality observed with that expected from mortality rates in the general population indicated three times the expected number of deaths from non-neoplastic causes. Five times the expected number of deaths from cardiovascular causes were observed, these were predominantly myocardial infarction and cerebrovascular accidents. There was no evidence of an excess in the number of suicides observed, but there were three times the expected number of deaths from accidents observed after central nervous system tumours. Two groups of patients were identified whose deaths were potentially avoidable. Seven patients with craniopharyngioma and panhypopituitarism presented with addisonian crises during periods of stress not adequately covered by exogenous corticosteroids. In the other group were children who received radiotherapy and later developed problems related to radiation fibrosis. We emphasize that our investigation relates to patients diagnosed with childhood cancer before 1971. The pattern of mortality that will emerge after recent treatment regimens, in which chemotherapy is being used more extensively, is likely to be different from that observed in our study.
对1971年前在英国被诊断为儿童癌症且存活至少五年的4082名患者中的749例死亡病例进行了调查。在738例有足够信息的病例中,归因于以下原因的死亡人数分别为:肿瘤复发,550例(74%);第二原发性肿瘤,61例(8%);与肿瘤治疗相关的医疗状况,49例(7%);与肿瘤或其治疗无关的创伤性死亡,34例(5%);最后,与肿瘤或其治疗无关的任何其他原因,44例(6%)。非霍奇金淋巴瘤、神经母细胞瘤、视网膜母细胞瘤、肾母细胞瘤或软组织肉瘤的五年幸存者中,不到10%在接下来的15年中死于肿瘤复发,而霍奇金病、室管膜瘤、髓母细胞瘤和尤因肉瘤的五年幸存者中,超过25%在相应时期死于肿瘤复发。急性淋巴细胞白血病的五年幸存者中,近50%在相应的15年中死于疾病复发,在常规进行中枢神经系统预防之前的时代,很大一部分死亡是由于中枢神经系统复发。将观察到的死亡率与一般人群死亡率预期值进行比较,结果显示非肿瘤原因导致的死亡人数是预期值的三倍。观察到心血管原因导致的死亡人数是预期值的五倍,主要是心肌梗死和脑血管意外。没有证据表明观察到的自杀人数过多,但中枢神经系统肿瘤后观察到的意外死亡人数是预期值的三倍。确定了两组患者,其死亡可能是可以避免的。7例颅咽管瘤和全垂体功能减退患者在应激期间出现肾上腺皮质功能减退危象,而外源性皮质类固醇未充分覆盖这些应激期。另一组是接受放疗后后来出现与放射性纤维化相关问题的儿童。我们强调,我们的调查涉及1971年前被诊断为儿童癌症的患者。在最近更广泛使用化疗的治疗方案之后出现的死亡率模式可能与我们研究中观察到的不同。