Verity Software House, Topsham, Maine 04086, USA.
Cytometry B Clin Cytom. 2012 Sep;82(5):313-8. doi: 10.1002/cyto.b.21032. Epub 2012 Jul 11.
Flow Cytometry is widely used for enumeration of hematopoietic stem cell (SC) levels in bone marrow, cord blood, peripheral blood, and apheresis products. The ISHAGE single-platform gating method is considered by many to be the standard for CD34+ SC enumeration. However, attempts at uniform application of this ISHAGE method have met with only partial success. We propose an automated, multivariate classification approach for SC analysis based on Probability State Modeling™ (PSM). In this study, we compare the results from automated PSM analysis with manual ISHAGE gating analysis as performed by a trained analyst.
A total of 258 samples were assayed on BD FACSCanto II flow cytometers using a stain-lyse-no-wash technique. Populations were defined using CD34, CD45, 7-AAD, and light scatter. BD TruCount™ bead tubes were used for absolute SC concentrations. A PSM was designed to classify events into beads, debris, intact-dead cells, and intact-live SC; run unattended and record results.
The ISHAGE and PSM methods show excellent agreement in estimating the concentration of #SC/μL: slope = 1.009, r² = 0.999. Bland-Altman Analysis for the SC concentration has an average difference (bias) of 2.018 SC/μL. The 95% confidence interval is from -59.350 to 63.380 SC/μL. The operator-to-operator agreement using PSM is perfect: r² = 1.000.
Automated PSM analysis of SC listmode data produces results that agree strongly with ISHAGE gate-based results. The PSM approach provides higher reproducibility, objectivity, and speed with accuracy at least equivalent to the ISHAGE method.
流式细胞术广泛用于骨髓、脐血、外周血和单采产品中造血干细胞(SC)水平的计数。ISHAGE 单平台门控方法被许多人认为是 CD34+SC 计数的标准。然而,尝试统一应用这种 ISHAGE 方法仅取得了部分成功。我们提出了一种基于概率状态建模(PSM)的自动化、多变量 SC 分析分类方法。在这项研究中,我们将自动 PSM 分析的结果与经过培训的分析师执行的手动 ISHAGE 门控分析的结果进行了比较。
总共对 258 个样本在 BD FACSCanto II 流式细胞仪上使用染色-裂解-不洗涤技术进行了检测。使用 CD34、CD45、7-AAD 和光散射来定义群体。使用 BD TruCount™珠子管进行绝对 SC 浓度的测定。设计了一个 PSM 来将事件分类为珠子、碎片、完整-死亡细胞和完整-活 SC;无人值守运行并记录结果。
ISHAGE 和 PSM 方法在估计 #SC/μL 的浓度方面显示出极好的一致性:斜率=1.009,r²=0.999。SC 浓度的 Bland-Altman 分析平均差异(偏差)为 2.018 SC/μL。95%置信区间为 -59.350 至 63.380 SC/μL。使用 PSM 的操作员间一致性是完美的:r²=1.000。
对 SC 列表模式数据进行自动 PSM 分析产生的结果与基于 ISHAGE 门控的结果非常吻合。PSM 方法提供了更高的可重复性、客观性和速度,准确性至少与 ISHAGE 方法相当。