London Region Epidemiology Unit, Health Protection Agency (HPA), London, UK.
Euro Surveill. 2012 Jun 21;17(25):20202.
The use of the case-cohort design for outbreak investigations has been limited. Here we discuss its strengths and limitations based on real and fictitious examples. The case-cohort is a case–control study where controls are sampled from the initial population at risk, and may thus include both cases and non-cases. An advantage of the design, compared to traditional case-control studies, is that risk ratios can easily be obtained directly from the cross-product of exposed and unexposed cases and controls (rare disease assumption is not required). We illustrate this in the context of point source gastrointestinal outbreaks and in field studies on vaccine effectiveness. The design is also useful to investigate multiple outcomes with a unique sample of controls or to test hypotheses when different case-definitions (from the most sensitive to the most specific) are used for a particular outcome. Strengths and limitations are presented, and discussed in the context of outbreak investigations.
病例-对照设计在暴发调查中的应用受到限制。本文通过真实和虚构的例子,讨论了该设计的优缺点。病例-对照是一种病例对照研究,其中对照是从初始危险人群中抽取的,因此可能包括病例和非病例。与传统病例对照研究相比,该设计的一个优点是,风险比可以直接从暴露和未暴露病例和对照的交叉乘积中获得(不需要罕见病假设)。我们在点源胃肠道暴发和疫苗效力现场研究中说明了这一点。该设计还可用于用独特的对照样本调查多种结果,或在为特定结果使用不同的病例定义(从最敏感到最具体)时检验假设。本文介绍了该设计的优缺点,并结合暴发调查进行了讨论。