Department of Zoology and Biodiversity Research Centre, University of British Columbia, 2212 Main Mall, Vancouver, British Columbia V6T 1Z4, Canada.
Am Nat. 2012 Aug;180(2):225-45. doi: 10.1086/666649. Epub 2012 Jun 20.
Variation in diversification rates is often studied by investigating traits related to species' ecology and life history. Often, however, it is unknown whether these traits evolve gradually or in punctuated bursts during speciation. Using phylogenetic data and species' present-day trait information, we present a novel approach to assessing the mode of character change while accounting for trait-dependent speciation and extinction. Our model, "Binary-State Speciation and Extinction-node enhanced state shift" (BiSSE-ness), estimates both the rate of change occurring along lineages and the probability of change occurring during speciation, as well as independent speciation and extinction rates for each character state. Using simulations, we found that BiSSE-ness is able to distinguish along-lineage and speciational change and accurately estimate the parameters associated with character change and diversification rates. We applied BiSSE-ness to an empirical primate data set and found evidence for along-lineage changes in primate mating systems and social behaviors, whereas shifts in habitat were associated with speciation. In cases where trait changes may be linked to the speciation process itself (e.g., niche-related traits), BiSSE-ness provides a suitable framework with which to simultaneously address questions regarding species diversification and character change.
物种多样化速率的变化通常通过研究与物种生态和生活史相关的特征来研究。然而,这些特征是逐渐进化的,还是在物种形成过程中以间断平衡的方式进化的,往往并不清楚。本研究利用系统发育数据和物种当前的特征信息,提出了一种新的方法来评估特征变化的模式,同时考虑了特征相关的物种形成和灭绝。我们的模型“二元状态物种形成和灭绝-增强状态转移”(BiSSE-ness),同时估计了沿谱系发生的变化率以及在物种形成过程中发生变化的概率,以及每个特征状态的独立物种形成和灭绝率。通过模拟,我们发现 BiSSE-ness 能够区分沿谱系和物种形成的变化,并准确估计与特征变化和多样化速率相关的参数。我们将 BiSSE-ness 应用于一个灵长类动物的经验数据集,发现灵长类动物交配系统和社会行为沿谱系发生变化的证据,而栖息地的变化与物种形成有关。在特征变化可能与物种形成过程本身相关的情况下(例如,与生态位相关的特征),BiSSE-ness 提供了一个合适的框架,可以同时解决有关物种多样化和特征变化的问题。