Stanisić M, Rzepa T
Department of General and Vascular Surgery, Poznań University of Medical Sciences, Poznań, Poland.
Int Angiol. 2012 Aug;31(4):376-85.
Two most frequent asymptomatic diseases qualifying for vascular surgery are abdominal aortic aneurysm (AAA) and internal carotid artery stenosis (ICAS). Emotions experienced by the patient activate processes of dealing with the cognitive dissonance of asymptomatic disease. The aim of this paper was to compare the reasons involved in decision making on surgery in two asymptomatic vascular pathologies.
Fifty patients were divided into two groups: the ICAS group-27 (CAS or CEA) and the AAA group-23 (EVAR or open surgical operation (OSR). Specific questionnaire regarding: 1) self-image; 2) attitude to one's illness; 3) reasons for decision on surgery was applied for the study. The χ² test was used to for the analysis.
The AAA patients reacted emotionally (88.2%) comparing to ICAS patients reacting "rationally" (59.3%) (α=0.05). In AAA patients attitude towards themselves had worsened (α=0.001) AAA patients were less likely to seek support in decision on surgery (α=0.01). ICAS patients are internally motivated (78.7%), whereas AAA patients are externally motivated (63.9%) (α=0.001). Reasons underlying the decision on surgery, were predominantly rational (55.8%).
In the process of decision-making on surgery by asymptomatic patients, evolutionary transformation takes place - the emotional attitude to one's illness leads to rationally evaluated decision. Regardless of the causes the process of making a decision on surgical operation tended to run more smoothly in ICAS patients. The ICAS patients tended to display a rational attitude to their illness. AAA patients displayed a distinctly emotional attitude towards their illness.
有资格接受血管手术的两种最常见的无症状疾病是腹主动脉瘤(AAA)和颈内动脉狭窄(ICAS)。患者所经历的情绪会激活应对无症状疾病认知失调的过程。本文的目的是比较两种无症状血管病变患者手术决策所涉及的原因。
50名患者被分为两组:ICAS组27例(接受颈动脉支架置入术或颈动脉内膜切除术)和AAA组23例(接受腔内血管修复术或开放手术)。应用一份关于以下方面的特定问卷进行研究:1)自我形象;2)对自身疾病的态度;3)手术决策的原因。采用χ²检验进行分析。
与“理性”反应的ICAS患者(59.3%)相比,AAA患者有情绪反应的比例为88.2%(α=0.05)。AAA患者对自己的态度变差(α=0.001),AAA患者在手术决策中寻求支持的可能性较小(α=0.01)。ICAS患者是内在动机驱动(78.7%),而AAA患者是外在动机驱动(63.9%)(α=0.001)。手术决策的主要原因是理性的(55.8%)。
在无症状患者的手术决策过程中发生了进化转变——对自身疾病的情感态度导致了经过理性评估的决策。无论原因如何,ICAS患者的手术决策过程往往更顺利。ICAS患者对自己的疾病倾向于表现出理性态度。AAA患者对自己的疾病表现出明显的情感态度。