Wernecke K, Vassallo P, Peters P E, Pötter R, Lückener H G
Abteilung Röntgendiagnostik, Westfälische Wilhelms-Universität Münster.
Radiologe. 1990 Nov;30(11):532-40.
The purpose of this prospective study was to evaluate the sensitivity of mediastinal sonography compared to CT and chest radiography in the detection of mediastinal tumors. The sonograms, computed tomograms and chest radiographs of 182 patients were interpreted blindly by three observers and the results of all three procedures were compared. The proportion of diagnostic sonographic examinations varied in the different mediastinal compartments from 85% (subcarinal region) to 96% (supra-aortic region). The sensitivities of sonography and chest radiography (using CT as the gold standard) in the imaging of mediastinal tumors for each compartment were as follows: supra-aortic region: 98% and 67%; paratracheal region: 89% and 69%; aorticopulmonary window: 81% and 62%; prevascular region: 92% and 46%; subcarinal region: 69% and 31%; pericardial region: 100% and 67%; posterior mediastinum: 6% and 6%; paravertebral region: 11% and 44%. These results show that sonography is superior to chest radiography for the diagnosis of mediastinal tumors. In certain mediastinal regions (supra-aortic, pericardial, prevascular and paratracheal region), sonography is so sensitive that CT and MR examinations may be avoided in cases with equivocal radiographic findings.
这项前瞻性研究的目的是评估纵隔超声相对于CT和胸部X线摄影在检测纵隔肿瘤方面的敏感性。由三名观察者对182例患者的超声图像、计算机断层扫描图像和胸部X线片进行盲法解读,并比较这三种检查方法的结果。在不同的纵隔区域,诊断性超声检查的比例从85%(隆突下区域)到96%(主动脉弓上区域)不等。超声检查和胸部X线摄影(以CT作为金标准)在各纵隔区域纵隔肿瘤成像中的敏感性如下:主动脉弓上区域:98%和67%;气管旁区域:89%和69%;主动脉肺动脉窗:81%和62%;血管前区域:92%和46%;隆突下区域:69%和31%;心包区域:100%和67%;后纵隔:6%和6%;椎旁区域:11%和44%。这些结果表明,超声检查在纵隔肿瘤诊断方面优于胸部X线摄影。在某些纵隔区域(主动脉弓上、心包、血管前和气管旁区域),超声检查非常敏感,在影像学表现不明确的病例中,可能无需进行CT和MR检查。