Mahoney Amanda, Weetjens Bart J, Cox Christophe, Beyene Negussie, Reither Klaus, Makingi George, Jubitana Maureen, Kazwala Rudovick, Mfinanga Godfrey S, Kahwa Amos, Durgin Amy, Poling Alan
Department of Psychology, Western Michigan University, Kalamazoo, MI 49008-5200, USA.
Tuberc Res Treat. 2012;2012:716989. doi: 10.1155/2012/716989. Epub 2012 Jul 9.
Setting. Tanzania. Objective. To compare microscopy as conducted in direct observation of treatment, short course centers to pouched rats as detectors of Mycobacterium tuberculosis. Design. Ten pouched rats were trained to detect tuberculosis in sputum using operant conditioning techniques. The rats evaluated 910 samples previously evaluated by smear microscopy. All samples were also evaluated through culturing and multiplex polymerase chain reaction was performed on culture growths to classify the bacteria. Results. The patientwise sensitivity of microscopy was 58.0%, and the patient-wise specificity was 97.3%. Used as a group of 10 with a cutoff (defined as the number of rat indications to classify a sample as positive for Mycobacterium tuberculosis) of 1, the rats increased new case detection by 46.8% relative to microscopy alone. The average samplewise sensitivity of the individual rats was 68.4% (range 61.1-73.8%), and the mean specificity was 87.3% (range 84.7-90.3%). Conclusion. These results suggest that pouched rats are a valuable adjunct to, and may be a viable substitute for, sputum smear microscopy as a tuberculosis diagnostic in resource-poor countries.
研究背景。坦桑尼亚。研究目的。比较在直接观察治疗短期中心进行的显微镜检查与袋狸作为结核分枝杆菌检测工具的效果。研究设计。使用操作性条件反射技术训练10只袋狸检测痰液中的结核病。这些袋狸对之前经涂片显微镜检查评估过的910份样本进行了评估。所有样本也通过培养进行了评估,并对培养生长物进行了多重聚合酶链反应以对细菌进行分类。研究结果。显微镜检查的患者层面敏感性为58.0%,患者层面特异性为97.3%。作为一组10只使用,设定阈值(定义为将一个样本分类为结核分枝杆菌阳性的袋狸指示数)为1时,相对于单独使用显微镜检查,袋狸使新病例检测增加了46.8%。个体袋狸的平均样本层面敏感性为68.4%(范围61.1 - 73.8%),平均特异性为87.3%(范围84.7 - 90.3%)。研究结论。这些结果表明,在资源匮乏国家,袋狸作为结核病诊断工具,是痰液涂片显微镜检查的有价值辅助手段,并且可能是可行的替代方法。