Ribeiro Cristina
Departamento de Medicina Geral e Familiar, Faculdade de Medicina de Lisboa, Lisboa, Portugal.
Acta Med Port. 2011 Dec;24 Suppl 2:355-68. Epub 2011 Dec 31.
Evaluate if Brief Interventions are effective to reduce alcohol consumption of patients detected as risky consumers; Evaluate if the Physicians' training on Brief Interventions to approach alcohol consumption related problems (ARP) contributes to change their attitudes towards hazardous and harmful alcohol consumers.
The study had two distinct phases. One phase of characterization and assessment of SAAPPQ in a random sample of physicians in the District of Lisbon (Phase 1), and another phase with two components: 1) examine the perceived attitudes of FPs/GPs towards alcohol consumption of their patients before training and again nine months after training, when they were already using early identification and brief intervention (EIBI) in their clinical practice; 2) determine whether the clinical competences of the FPs/GPs had improved in detecting and intervening next to their patients with hazardous or harmful alcohol consumption, after the training in Brief Interventions. This detection was measured by the AUDIT questionnaire, applied again to the patients nine months after the first time (Phase 2).
Physicians in the experimental group at T2 felt more motivated, had higher self-esteem and were more satisfied than the control group. There was a positive development of the attitude of physicians from the first stage to the second stage, especially in the physicians of the experimental group. PATIENTS (T1)--In the sample of patients to whom AUDIT was applied, 60% were female and the mean age was 54 years. It was observed that 21% of the patients had some risky alcohol consumption (AUDIT C). Patients (T1 and T2)--In the sample of patients with risk consumption, 62% were male and the mean age was 55 years old. Patients followed by a physician of the experimental group (compared to patients followed by a physician of the control group) had an increase of 54% in the success rate in reduction of, at least, one point on the AUDIT, from the first to the second stage of the study. In the first stage of the study, the consumption of alcohol (in grams) was homogeneous between groups and an average of 193 grams of alcohol consumption per week was observed. In the second instance of the study, the average alcohol consumption was 145 grams of alcohol per week. This decrease in consumption was observed mainly on patients followed by physicians of the experimental group. Relationship between physicians and patients--Results concerning the relationship between physicians and patients demonstrates that a better attitude of physicians in relation to ARP can influence the decrease in alcohol consumption of those patients (from the first to the second stage of the study).
评估简短干预措施对于减少被检测出为高风险饮酒者的患者的酒精摄入量是否有效;评估医生接受针对处理与饮酒相关问题(ARP)的简短干预培训是否有助于改变他们对危险和有害饮酒者的态度。
该研究有两个不同阶段。一个阶段是对里斯本地区随机抽取的医生样本进行SAAPPQ的特征描述和评估(第一阶段),另一个阶段有两个部分:1)检查家庭医生/全科医生(FPs/GPs)在培训前以及培训九个月后(此时他们已在临床实践中使用早期识别和简短干预(EIBI))对其患者饮酒情况的感知态度;2)确定在接受简短干预培训后,FPs/GPs在检测和干预有危险或有害饮酒行为的患者方面的临床能力是否有所提高。这种检测通过AUDIT问卷进行,在首次应用九个月后再次应用于患者(第二阶段)。
在T2时,实验组的医生比对照组更有动力、自尊心更强且更满意。从第一阶段到第二阶段,医生的态度有积极变化,尤其是实验组的医生。患者(T1)——在应用AUDIT问卷的患者样本中,60%为女性,平均年龄为54岁。观察到21%的患者有一些危险饮酒行为(AUDIT C)。患者(T1和T2)——在有风险饮酒行为的患者样本中,62%为男性,平均年龄为55岁。由实验组医生随访的患者(与由对照组医生随访的患者相比),从研究的第一阶段到第二阶段,在AUDIT量表上至少降低一分的成功率提高了54%。在研究的第一阶段,各组之间的酒精摄入量(以克为单位)是均匀的,观察到平均每周酒精摄入量为193克。在研究的第二个阶段,平均酒精摄入量为每周145克。这种摄入量的减少主要在由实验组医生随访的患者中观察到。医生与患者的关系——关于医生与患者关系的结果表明,医生对ARP的更好态度可以影响这些患者的酒精摄入量减少(从研究的第一阶段到第二阶段)。