Department of Dermatology, Centre Hospitalier Lyon Sud, 69495 Pierre-Bénite Cedex, France.
Br J Dermatol. 2013 Jan;168(1):74-9. doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2133.2012.11216.x. Epub 2012 Dec 17.
Dermoscopy is now recognized as an essential tool for discriminating melanoma from other pigmented lesions, as corroborated by several robust meta-analyses. Although it is considered to be widely used in European countries, no published data on this topic are available to date, unlike in Australia and the U.S.A.
To describe and quantify the use and learning of dermoscopy among French private practice dermatologists.
A questionnaire of 19 items regarding demographic characteristics, dermoscopy use and training, and physician's judgment on dermoscopy was mailed to all French private practice dermatologists. Only questionnaires with an answer to the key item, 'Do you use dermoscopy?' were taken into account.
Of 3179 mailed questionnaires, 1611 were returned and 1576 were analysable (49·6%). Most respondents declared using dermoscopy (94·6%), using their dermoscope several times a day (82·7%) and/or for the diagnosis of nonpigmented lesions (87·7%). Physicians learned dermoscopy mainly through books (75·8%) and/or conferences (88·6%); 12·8% reported a dedicated university degree. Dermoscopy helps to detect melanoma earlier and to perform fewer biopsies according to 86·6% and 74·6%, respectively. On multivariate analysis, female sex and age under 45 years were significantly associated with higher utilization rate of dermoscopy [odds ratio 1·89, 95% confidence interval (CI) 1·15-3·10; and 2·85, 95% CI 1·14-7·11, respectively].
This is the first published nationwide survey of dermoscopy practice in Europe. Despite potential classification and/or selection bias, the particularly high penetration rate found in our study suggests that dermoscopy is now widely accepted by French private practice dermatologists for the routine management of both pigmented and nonpigmented lesions.
皮肤镜检查现在被认为是鉴别黑色素瘤与其他色素性病变的重要工具,这一点已被多项强有力的荟萃分析所证实。尽管它被认为在欧洲国家被广泛使用,但迄今为止,与澳大利亚和美国不同,没有关于这一主题的已发表数据。
描述和量化法国私人执业皮肤科医生中皮肤镜的使用和学习情况。
向所有法国私人执业皮肤科医生邮寄了一份包含 19 个项目的问卷,内容涉及人口统计学特征、皮肤镜的使用和培训,以及医生对皮肤镜的判断。只有回答了关键问题“您是否使用皮肤镜?”的问卷才被纳入分析。
在寄出的 3179 份问卷中,有 1611 份被退回,其中 1576 份可分析(占 49.6%)。大多数受访者表示使用皮肤镜(94.6%),每天使用皮肤镜数次(82.7%),或用于诊断非色素性病变(87.7%)。医生主要通过书籍(75.8%)和/或会议(88.6%)学习皮肤镜;12.8%的人报告有专门的大学学位。86.6%和 74.6%的医生认为皮肤镜有助于更早发现黑色素瘤和减少活检次数。多变量分析显示,女性和年龄小于 45 岁与皮肤镜使用率较高显著相关[比值比 1.89,95%置信区间(CI)1.15-3.10;2.85,95%CI 1.14-7.11]。
这是欧洲首次发表的关于皮肤镜检查实践的全国性调查。尽管存在潜在的分类和/或选择偏倚,但我们的研究发现皮肤镜的使用率特别高,这表明它现在已被法国私人执业皮肤科医生广泛接受,用于常规管理色素性和非色素性病变。