Consultant in Pharmaceutical Medicine, London, UK.
Hum Vaccin Immunother. 2012 Oct;8(10):1431-8. doi: 10.4161/hv.20629. Epub 2012 Aug 16.
Despite of growing oncology pipeline, cancer vaccines contribute only to a minor share of total oncology-attributed revenues. This is mainly because of a limited number of approved products and limited sales from products approved under compassionate or via early access entry in smaller and less developed markets. However revenue contribution from these products is extremely limited and it remains to be established whether developers are breaking even or achieving profitability with existing sales. Cancer vaccine field is well recognized for high development costs and risks, low historical rates of investment return and high probability of failures arising in ventures, partnerships and alliances. The cost of reimbursement for new oncology agents is not universally acceptable to payers limiting the potential for a global expansion, market access and reducing probability of commercial success. In addition, the innovation in cancer immunotherapy is currently focused in small and mid-size biotech companies and academic institutions struggling for investment. Existing R&D innovation models are deemed unsustainable in current "value-for-money" oriented healthcare environment. New business models should be much more open to collaborative, networked and federated styles, which could help to outreach global, markets and increase cost-efficiencies across an entire value chain. Lessons learned from some developing countries and especially from South Korea illustrate that further growth of cancer vaccine industry will depends not only on new business models but also will heavily rely on regional support and initiatives from different bodies, such as governments, payers and regulatory bodies.
尽管肿瘤学领域的研究不断发展,但癌症疫苗在肿瘤学相关收入中仅占很小的一部分。这主要是由于批准的产品数量有限,以及在较小和欠发达市场中通过同情用药或早期准入途径批准的产品的销售额有限。然而,这些产品的收入贡献极其有限,开发商是否通过现有销售实现收支平衡或盈利仍有待确定。癌症疫苗领域以高开发成本和风险、低历史投资回报率以及风险投资、合作伙伴关系和联盟中失败的高概率而闻名。新肿瘤药物的报销成本对支付方来说并不普遍接受,这限制了全球扩张、市场准入的潜力,并降低了商业成功的可能性。此外,癌症免疫疗法的创新目前集中在小型和中型生物技术公司和学术机构,它们正在努力寻求投资。现有的研发创新模式在当前以“物有所值”为导向的医疗保健环境中被认为是不可持续的。新的商业模式应该更加开放地采用合作、网络化和联合的模式,这有助于拓展全球市场,并提高整个价值链的成本效益。一些发展中国家,特别是韩国的经验教训表明,癌症疫苗行业的进一步增长不仅取决于新的商业模式,还将严重依赖不同机构(如政府、支付方和监管机构)的区域支持和举措。