Guzman Marco, Angulo Mabel, Muñoz Daniel, Mayerhoff Ross
University of Chile, Santiago, Chile.
Int J Speech Lang Pathol. 2013 Apr;15(2):127-35. doi: 10.3109/17549507.2012.702283. Epub 2012 Aug 22.
Abstract This case-control study aimed to investigate if there is any change on the spectral slope declination immediately after vocal function exercises (VFE) vs traditional vocal warm-up exercises in normal singers. Thirty-eight pop singers with perceptually normal voices were divided into two groups: an experimental group (n = 20) and a control group (n = 18). One single session with VFE for the experimental group and traditional singing warm-up exercises for the control group was applied. Voice was recorded before and after the exercises. The recorded tasks were to read a phonetically balanced text and to sing a song. Long-term average spectrum (LTAS) analysis included alpha ratio, L1-L0 ratio, and singing power ratio (SPR). Acoustic parameters of voice samples pre- and post-training were compared. Comparison between VFE and control group was also performed. Significant changes after treatment included the alpha ratio and singing power ratio in speaking voice, and SPR in the singing voice for VFE group. The traditional vocal warm-up of the control group also showed pre-post changes. Significant differences between VFE group and control group for alpha ratio and SPR were found in speaking voice samples. This study demonstrates that VFE have an immediate effect on the spectrum of the voice, specifically a decrease on the spectral slope declination. The results of this study provide support for the advantageous effect of VFE as vocal warm-up on voice quality.
摘要 本病例对照研究旨在调查正常歌手在进行发声功能训练(VFE)后与传统发声热身训练后,其频谱斜率偏斜度是否有任何变化。38名嗓音感知正常的流行歌手被分为两组:实验组(n = 20)和对照组(n = 18)。实验组进行了一次VFE训练,对照组进行了传统的歌唱热身训练。训练前后对嗓音进行录音。录音任务包括朗读一篇语音平衡的文本和演唱一首歌。长期平均谱(LTAS)分析包括α比率、L1 - L0比率和歌唱功率比(SPR)。比较了训练前后嗓音样本的声学参数。还对VFE组和对照组进行了比较。治疗后,VFE组的显著变化包括说话嗓音中的α比率和歌唱功率比,以及歌唱嗓音中的SPR。对照组的传统发声热身训练也显示出训练前后的变化。在说话嗓音样本中,发现VFE组和对照组在α比率和SPR方面存在显著差异。本研究表明,VFE对嗓音频谱有即时影响,特别是频谱斜率偏斜度降低。本研究结果为VFE作为嗓音热身对嗓音质量的有益作用提供了支持。