Rutherford Kenneth M D, Donald Ramona D, Lawrence Alistair B, Wemelsfelder Françoise
Animal Behaviour and Welfare, Animal and Veterinary Sciences Research Group, SAC, West Mains Rd., Edinburgh, EH9 3JG, Scotland, United Kingdom.
Appl Anim Behav Sci. 2012 Jul;139(3-4):218-224. doi: 10.1016/j.applanim.2012.04.004.
Scientific assessment of affective states in animals is challenging but vital for animal welfare studies. One possible approach is Qualitative Behavioural Assessment (QBA), a 'whole animal' methodology which integrates information from multiple behavioural signals and styles of behavioural expression (body language) directly in terms of an animal's emotional expression. If QBA provides a valid measure of animals' emotional state it should distinguish between groups where emotional states have been manipulated. To test this hypothesis, QBA was applied to video-recordings of pigs, following treatment with either saline or the neuroleptic drug Azaperone, in either an open field or elevated plus-maze test. QBA analysis of these recordings was provided by 12 observers, blind to treatment, using a Free Choice Profiling (FCP) methodology. Generalised Procrustes Analysis was used to calculate a consensus profile, consisting of the main dimensions of expression. Dimension one was positively associated with terms such as 'Confident' and 'Curious' and negatively with 'Unsure' and 'Nervous'. Dimension two ranged from 'Agitated'/'Angry' to 'Calm'/'Relaxed'. In both tests, Azaperone pre-treatment was associated with a more positive emotionality (higher scores on dimension one reflecting a more confident/curious behavioural demeanour) than control pigs. No effect of drug treatment on dimension two was found. Relationships between qualitative descriptions of behaviour and quantitative behavioural measures, taken from the same recordings, were found. Overall, this work supports the use of QBA for the assessment of emotionality in animals.
对动物情感状态进行科学评估具有挑战性,但对动物福利研究至关重要。一种可能的方法是定性行为评估(QBA),这是一种“整体动物”方法,它直接根据动物的情感表达,整合来自多种行为信号和行为表达风格(肢体语言)的信息。如果QBA能有效衡量动物的情绪状态,那么它应该能够区分情绪状态受到操控的不同组。为了验证这一假设,在旷场试验或高架十字迷宫试验中,对用生理盐水或抗精神病药物氮哌酮处理过的猪的视频记录应用QBA。12名对处理情况不知情的观察者使用自由选择剖析(FCP)方法对这些记录进行QBA分析。广义普罗克拉斯提斯分析用于计算一个共识概况,该概况由表达的主要维度组成。维度一与“自信”和“好奇”等术语呈正相关,与“不确定”和“紧张”呈负相关。维度二的范围从“激动”/“愤怒”到“平静”/“放松”。在两项试验中,与对照猪相比,氮哌酮预处理与更积极的情绪(维度一得分更高,反映出更自信/好奇的行为举止)相关。未发现药物处理对维度二有影响。从相同记录中发现了行为的定性描述与定量行为测量之间的关系。总体而言,这项工作支持使用QBA来评估动物的情绪。