Unité de Recherche en Maladies Infectieuses Tropical Emergentes, CNRS-IRD UMR 6236-198, Université de la Méditerranée Marseille, France.
Front Cell Infect Microbiol. 2011 Oct 31;1:8. doi: 10.3389/fcimb.2011.00008. eCollection 2011.
Many of the definitions in microbiology are currently false. We have reviewed the great denominations of microbiology and attempted to free microorganisms from the theories of the twentieth century. The presence of compartmentation and a nucleoid in Planctomycetes clearly calls into question the accuracy of the definitions of eukaryotes and prokaryotes. Archaea are viewed as prokaryotes resembling bacteria. However, the name archaea, suggesting an archaic origin of lifestyle, is inconsistent with the lifestyle of this family. Viruses are defined as small, filterable infectious agents, but giant viruses challenge the size criteria used for the definition of a virus. Pathogenicity does not require the acquisition of virulence factors (except for toxins), and in many cases, gene loss is significantly inked to the emergence of virulence. Species classification based on 16S rRNA is useless for taxonomic purposes of human pathogens, as a 2% divergence would classify all Rickettsiae within the same species and would not identify bacteria specialized for mammal infection. The use of metagenomics helps us to understand evolution and physiology by elucidating the structure, function, and interactions of the major microbial communities, but it neglects the minority populations. Finally, Darwin's descent with modification theory, as represented by the tree of life, no longer matches our current genomic knowledge because genomics has revealed the occurrence of de novo-created genes and the mosaic structure of genomes, the Rhizome of life is therefore more appropriate.
许多微生物学的定义目前都是错误的。我们回顾了微生物学的重要命名,并试图使微生物摆脱二十世纪的理论。厚壁菌门中分隔区和拟核的存在,显然对真核生物和原核生物定义的准确性提出了质疑。古菌被视为类似细菌的原核生物。然而,古菌这个名字暗示了它们生活方式的古老起源,这与该家族的生活方式不一致。病毒被定义为体积小、可滤过的传染性病原体,但巨型病毒对用于定义病毒的大小标准提出了挑战。致病性并不需要获得毒力因子(除了毒素),在许多情况下,基因丢失与毒力的出现显著相关。基于 16S rRNA 的物种分类对于人类病原体的分类目的来说是无用的,因为 2%的差异会将所有立克次体归入同一物种,并且无法识别专门感染哺乳动物的细菌。宏基因组学的使用通过阐明主要微生物群落的结构、功能和相互作用,帮助我们理解进化和生理学,但它忽略了少数群体。最后,以生命之树为代表的达尔文进化论,不再符合我们当前的基因组知识,因为基因组学揭示了新创造基因的出现和基因组的镶嵌结构,因此生命之根的概念更为恰当。