Lipsman Nir, Meyerson Björn A, Lozano Andres M
Division of Neurosurgery, Toronto Western Hospital, University of Toronto, Toronto, Ont., Canada. nir.lipsman @ utoronto.ca
Stereotact Funct Neurosurg. 2012;90(6):347-55. doi: 10.1159/000341082. Epub 2012 Aug 23.
In order to reconcile the present resurgence of psychiatric neurosurgery with the not-too-distant historic transgressions in the field, one needs to examine the era of transition from crude art to regulated science. In large part, this transition took place in the 1970s with the continued development and widespread acceptance of stereotactic techniques in functional neurosurgery and several hard-fought ideological and academic victories by proponents of the much-maligned field. Established in 1970, the International Society for Psychiatric Surgery (ISPS) sought to gather like-minded surgeons, psychiatrists and other neuroscientists to counter the rising pressure from special interest groups, as well as some in the public and medical realm, who attempted to abolish all forms of surgical management of psychiatric disease. We reviewed the archives of the ISPS, including letters from its founding members and active participants, conference proceedings and minutes from organizational meetings, from throughout its existence from 1970 to 1983. The archives provide a unique insight into the organization and objectives of the society that kept psychiatric surgery alive in the face of persistent and staunch opposition. We also outline the lessons that current and future functional neurosurgeons can learn from the ISPS, whose key figures, structure and communication, in the non-electronic era, were instrumental for the survival of psychiatric surgery during that critical period.
为了协调当前精神神经外科的复兴与该领域不久前的历史性违规行为,人们需要审视从粗糙技艺到规范科学的转变时代。很大程度上,这一转变发生在20世纪70年代,当时立体定向技术在功能神经外科持续发展并得到广泛认可,该备受诋毁的领域的支持者们在思想和学术上历经多次艰难的胜利。国际精神外科协会(ISPS)成立于1970年,旨在召集志同道合的外科医生、精神科医生和其他神经科学家,以应对来自特殊利益集团以及一些公众和医学领域人士日益增加的压力,这些人试图废除所有形式的精神疾病手术治疗。我们查阅了ISPS的档案,包括其创始成员和活跃参与者的信件、会议记录以及组织会议纪要,时间跨度为1970年至1983年该协会的整个存续期间。这些档案为该协会的组织和目标提供了独特的见解,该协会在持续而坚定的反对声中使精神外科得以存续。我们还概述了当前和未来的功能神经外科医生可以从ISPS学到的经验教训,在非电子时代,ISPS的关键人物、结构和沟通方式对精神外科在那个关键时期的生存起到了重要作用。