Jeanson Raphaël, Dussutour Audrey, Fourcassié Vincent
Centre de Recherches sur la Cognition Animale, Université de Toulouse, Université Paul Sabatier Toulouse, France.
Front Neurosci. 2012 Aug 20;6:121. doi: 10.3389/fnins.2012.00121. eCollection 2012.
In many species of group living invertebrates, in particular arthropods, collective decisions can emerge from the combined actions of individuals and the direct or indirect interactions between individuals. These decisions allow groups of individuals to respond quickly and accurately to changes that occur in their environment. Examples of such decisions are found in a variety of invertebrate taxa and in many different contexts, e.g., exploring a new territory, foraging for food, finding a suitable location where to aggregate or to establish a nest, defending oneself against predators, etc. In this paper we review the collective decisions that have been documented in different invertebrate taxa where individuals are known to live temporarily or permanently in social or gregarious groups. We first present some simple examples of collective decisions involving the choice between two alternatives. We then define the fundamental rules required for these collective decisions to emerge throughout the invertebrate taxon, from simple organisms such as caterpillars, to animals endowed with highly developed perceptive and cognitive capacities such as ants and bees. The presentation of these rules gives us the opportunity to illustrate one of the pitfalls of the study of collective choice in animals by showing through computer simulations how a choice between two alternatives can be misinterpreted as the result of the action of self-organized mechanisms. In the second part, we discuss the peculiarities of collective decisions in invertebrates, their properties, and characteristics. We conclude by discussing the issue of individual complexity in collective decision-making process.
在许多群居的无脊椎动物物种中,尤其是节肢动物,集体决策可源自个体的联合行动以及个体之间的直接或间接互动。这些决策使个体群体能够迅速且准确地应对其环境中发生的变化。此类决策的例子见于各种无脊椎动物分类群以及许多不同情境中,例如探索新领地、觅食、寻找合适的聚集或筑巢地点、抵御捕食者等。在本文中,我们回顾了在不同无脊椎动物分类群中记录的集体决策,在这些分类群中,已知个体临时或永久生活在社会群体或群居群体中。我们首先给出一些涉及在两种选择之间进行抉择的集体决策的简单例子。然后,我们定义这些集体决策在整个无脊椎动物分类群中出现所需的基本规则,从诸如毛虫等简单生物,到具有高度发达感知和认知能力的动物,如蚂蚁和蜜蜂。对这些规则的阐述使我们有机会通过计算机模拟展示在动物集体选择研究中的一个陷阱,即如何将两种选择之间的抉择错误地解释为自组织机制作用的结果。在第二部分,我们讨论无脊椎动物集体决策的特殊性、它们的属性和特征。我们通过讨论集体决策过程中个体复杂性的问题来得出结论。