Sligo GP Training Scheme, Sligo General Hospital, Sligo, Ireland.
Eur J Gen Pract. 2012 Sep;18(3):136-42. doi: 10.3109/13814788.2012.704360.
Termination of pregnancy (ToP) is currently illegal in Ireland. In 2010, more than 4000 women travelled from Ireland to the UK for a ToP.
The aims of this study were to assess the attitudes and clinical experiences of Irish General Practitioners (GPs) and GPs-in-training (GPRs) towards ToP.
A postal survey was sent to 500 GPs in Ireland. An internet-based survey was sent to 244 GPRs. Quantitative and qualitative analysis was performed.
Overall response was 44%. Four groups of doctor's opinions could be identified: (A) abortion can never be allowed (10%); (B) abortion can be allowed in limited circumstances (25%); (C) abortion should be available to all women (51%); and (D) no definite opinion (14%). Doctors in groups (A) and (B) were older and more often Catholic. Of doctors in group (C), 66% indicated an upper gestational limit of maximum 16 weeks. More than 40% of all respondents had at least one consultation specifically dealing with ToP within the past six months and 43% agreed with the statement that women's health suffers due to the travel related to ToP.
Most responding GPs and GPRs (75%) support the provision of ToP in Ireland in certain circumstances. The qualitative analysis of this survey showed that the terms pro-life and pro-choice inappropriately describe the spectrum of opinions. This study highlights clinical situations in which women's health may be adversely affected due to the requirement to travel for ToP.
在爱尔兰,终止妊娠(ToP)目前是非法的。2010 年,超过 4000 名爱尔兰妇女前往英国进行 ToP。
本研究旨在评估爱尔兰全科医生(GPs)和全科住院医师(GPRs)对 ToP 的态度和临床经验。
向爱尔兰的 500 名 GPs 发送了一份邮寄调查。向 244 名 GPRs 发送了一份基于互联网的调查。进行了定量和定性分析。
总体回复率为 44%。可以确定医生有以下四组观点:(A)永远不允许堕胎(10%);(B)可以在有限的情况下允许堕胎(25%);(C)所有妇女都应获得堕胎机会(51%);和(D)没有明确的意见(14%)。属于(A)和(B)组的医生年龄较大,且更常为天主教徒。属于(C)组的医生中,有 66%的人表示妊娠上限最高为 16 周。超过 40%的受访者在过去六个月内至少有一次专门针对 ToP 的咨询,并且 43%的人同意这样的说法,即由于与 ToP 相关的旅行,妇女的健康受到影响。
大多数回应的 GPs 和 GPRs(75%)支持在某些情况下在爱尔兰提供 ToP。这项调查的定性分析表明,“生命至上”和“选择自由”这两个术语不适当地描述了意见的范围。这项研究强调了由于需要旅行进行 ToP 而可能对妇女健康产生不利影响的临床情况。