Aiken Abigail R A, Johnson Dana M, Broussard Kathleen, Padron Elisa
LBJ School of Public Affairs, University of Texas at Austin, Austin, Texas, USA.
Population Research Center, University of Texas at Austin, Austin, Texas, USA.
BMJ Sex Reprod Health. 2018 May 15. doi: 10.1136/bmjsrh-2018-200113.
The Republic of Ireland has one of the world's most restrictive abortion laws, allowing abortion only to preserve a pregnant woman's life. We examined the impact of the law on women's options for accessing abortion, their decision-making regarding whichpathway to follow, and their experiences with their chosen approach.
We conducted semi-structured in-depth interviews with 38 women who had either travelled abroad to access abortion in a clinic or had self-managed a medical abortion at home using online telemedicine, between 2010 and 2017. We coded interview transcripts according to an iteratively developed coding guide and performed a thematic analysis to identify key themes.
We identified four key themes: (1) self-managing a medical abortion at home using online telemedicine can be a preference over travelling abroad to access abortion services; (2) regardless of the pathway chosen, women experience a lack of pre- and post-abortion support in the Irish healthcare system; (3) feelings of desperation while searching for safe abortion care can lead to considering or attempting dangerous methods; and (4) Irish abortion law and attitudes have impacts beyond physical health considerations, engendering shame and stigma.
Despite the country's restrictive abortion law, women in Ireland do obtain abortions, using methods that are legal and safe elsewhere. However, the law negatively impacts women's ability to discuss their options with their healthcare professionals and to seek follow-up care, and can have serious implications for their physical and emotional health. This study's findings provide evidence to inform public and policy discourse on Ireland's abortion laws.
爱尔兰共和国拥有世界上最严格的堕胎法律之一,仅允许为保护孕妇生命而进行堕胎。我们研究了该法律对女性获取堕胎途径的选择、她们关于选择何种途径的决策以及她们对所选方式的体验的影响。
我们对2010年至2017年间38名女性进行了半结构化深度访谈,这些女性要么出国到诊所进行堕胎,要么通过在线远程医疗在家自行进行药物流产。我们根据反复制定的编码指南对访谈记录进行编码,并进行主题分析以确定关键主题。
我们确定了四个关键主题:(1)与出国获取堕胎服务相比,通过在线远程医疗在家自行进行药物流产可能是一种更受青睐的选择;(2)无论选择何种途径,女性在爱尔兰医疗系统中都缺乏堕胎前后的支持;(3)在寻求安全堕胎护理时的绝望感可能导致考虑或尝试危险方法;(4)爱尔兰的堕胎法律和态度的影响超出了身体健康方面的考虑,会产生羞耻感和污名化。
尽管该国堕胎法律严格,但爱尔兰女性确实会通过在其他地方合法且安全的方法进行堕胎。然而,该法律对女性与医疗保健专业人员讨论其选择以及寻求后续护理的能力产生负面影响,并可能对她们的身心健康产生严重影响。本研究结果为有关爱尔兰堕胎法律的公众和政策讨论提供了参考依据。