Department of Emergency Medicine, Fujita Health University Hospital, 1-98 Kutsukake, Toyoake, Aichi 470-1192, Japan.
Environ Health Prev Med. 2013 Mar;18(2):130-5. doi: 10.1007/s12199-012-0301-y. Epub 2012 Sep 9.
The great majority of non-traumatic cardiac arrests (CA) occur at home. The toilet is a closed and private room where CA occurs frequently. However, due to the feelings of privacy that are associated with this room, the circumstances and causes of CA in the toilet have rarely been investigated.
A retrospective study was conducted to clarify clinical characteristics and resuscitation profiles of patients sustaining CA in the toilet.
Among 907 CA patients treated during a 4-year period, 101 (11 %) sustained CA in the toilet. While the collapse was witnessed in only 10 % of these patients, return of spontaneous circulation (ROSC) was achieved in 41 %. However, the long-term survival rate was 1 %. Multivariate regression analysis revealed that a history of cardiac diseases was predictive of CA in the toilet (odds ratio 3.045; 95 % confidence interval 1.756-5.282) but that there was no correlation with advanced age. The frequency of CA in the toilet may be influenced moderately by seasonal/circadian variations. The 101 patients were classified into four subgroups according to mode of discovery of CA. The frequency of ROSC was highest in those who collapsed in the presence of caregivers and lowest in those whose collapse were discovered later by family members being worried that the patient stayed in the toilet "too long." Imaging studies revealed life-threatening extra-cardiac lesions responsible for CA, such as subarachnoid hemorrhage and aortic dissection, in 23 % of the patient cohort.
The rarity of long-term survival among individuals sustaining CA in the toilet is mainly due to the delay in discovering the individual who collapsed. Although a history of cardiac diseases is a risk factor, predicting who may sustain CA in the toilet remains difficult due to etiological heterogeneity.
绝大多数非创伤性心脏骤停(CA)发生在家庭中。厕所是一个封闭且私人的房间,CA 经常发生在那里。然而,由于与该房间相关的隐私感,厕所中 CA 的情况和原因很少被调查。
进行了一项回顾性研究,以阐明在厕所中发生 CA 的患者的临床特征和复苏情况。
在 4 年期间治疗的 907 例 CA 患者中,有 101 例(11%)在厕所中发生 CA。虽然这些患者中只有 10%的人目睹了晕倒,但有 41%的人恢复了自主循环(ROSC)。然而,长期生存率仅为 1%。多变量回归分析显示,心脏病史是厕所中发生 CA 的预测因素(优势比 3.045;95%置信区间 1.756-5.282),但与年龄增长无关。厕所中 CA 的频率可能受到季节性/昼夜节律变化的适度影响。根据 CA 发现方式,将 101 例患者分为四个亚组。在有护理人员在场时晕倒的患者中 ROSC 频率最高,而那些因家人担心患者“在厕所呆太久”而发现晕倒的患者中 ROSC 频率最低。影像学研究显示,23%的患者队列存在危及生命的心脏外病变导致 CA,如蛛网膜下腔出血和主动脉夹层。
在厕所中发生 CA 的患者长期生存率低的主要原因是发现晕倒患者的时间延迟。虽然心脏病史是一个危险因素,但由于病因学的异质性,预测谁可能在厕所中发生 CA 仍然困难。