Borad Mitesh J, Curtis Kelly K, Babiker Hani M, Benjamin Martin, Tibes Raoul, Ramanathan Ramesh K, Wright Karen, Dueck Amylou C, Jameson Gayle, Von Hoff Daniel D
1. Department of Internal Medicine, Division of Hematology/Oncology, Mayo Clinic, Scottsdale, AZ;
J Cancer. 2012;3:345-53. doi: 10.7150/jca.4714. Epub 2012 Aug 17.
Concomitant medication (CM) use may result in Phase I cancer clinical trial ineligibility due to concern for potential CM-investigational drug interactions or alteration of investigational drug absorption. Few studies have examined the impact of CM use on trial eligibility.
We reviewed records of 274 patients on Phase I trials at a single academic institution. Demographics, CM identities and classes, CM discontinuation, reasons, and incidence of CM substitution were recorded. CM-investigational drug cytochrome P450 (CYP) enzyme interactions were documented. Statistical analysis was performed using descriptive statistics.
273 of 274 patients (99.6%, 95% confidence interval [CI] 98.9-100%) took CM, with a median of 8 CM per patient (range 0 - 42). CM discontinuation occurred in 67 cases (25%, 95% CI 19-30%). The most common CM classes discontinued were herbal (17 cases, 25%, 95% CI 16-37%) and proton pump inhibitors (15 cases, 22%, 95% CI 12-32%). CM discontinuation reasons were: protocol prohibition (32 cases, 48%, 95% CI 36-60%); potential CM-investigational drug interaction (25 cases, 37%, 95% CI 26-49%); other (10 cases, 15%, 95% CI 6-23%). A potential CM-investigational drug CYP interaction was noted in 122 cases (45%, 95% CI 39-50%). CM potentially weakly decreased investigational drug metabolism in 52 cases (43%, 95% CI 34-51%), and potentially strongly decreased investigational drug metabolism in 17 cases (14%, 95% CI 8-20%). Investigational drug potentially weakly decreased CM metabolism in 39 cases (32%, 95% CI 24-40%), and potentially strongly decreased CM metabolism in 28 cases (23%, 95% CI 15-30%). CM substitution occurred in 36/67 cases (54%, 95% CI 41-66%) where CM were discontinued to allow for eventual participation in clinical trials. Overall in 2 cases (0.7%, 95% CI 0.1-2.6%), patients were protocol ineligible because CM could not be discontinued or substituted.
This study highlights the high prevalence of concomitant medication use among cancer patients enrolled in phase I clinical trials. Most patients did meet trial eligibility criteria with careful substitution and discontinuation of CM. The most common reason for discontinuation of CM was protocol prohibition. The most common medications discontinued were herbal, proton pump inhibitors, selective serotonin reuptake inhibitor anti-depressants, and non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs.
由于担心合并用药(CM)与研究药物之间可能存在相互作用或影响研究药物的吸收,使用CM可能导致癌症I期临床试验不符合入组条件。很少有研究探讨使用CM对试验入组资格的影响。
我们回顾了一家学术机构中274例进行I期试验患者的记录。记录了人口统计学信息、CM的种类和名称、停用CM的情况、原因以及CM替代的发生率。记录了CM与研究药物之间细胞色素P450(CYP)酶的相互作用。使用描述性统计进行统计分析。
274例患者中有273例(99.6%,95%置信区间[CI]98.9 - 100%)使用了CM,每位患者使用CM的中位数为8种(范围0 - 42种)。67例(25%,95%CI 19 - 30%)患者停用了CM。最常停用的CM种类为草药(17例,25%,95%CI 16 - 37%)和质子泵抑制剂(15例,22%,95%CI 12 - 32%)。停用CM的原因有:方案禁止(32例,48%,95%CI 36 - 60%);CM与研究药物可能存在相互作用(25例,37%,95%CI 26 - 49%);其他(10例,15%,95%CI 6 - 23%)。122例(45%,95%CI 39 - 50%)患者存在CM与研究药物之间潜在的CYP相互作用。CM可能使研究药物代谢轻度降低的有52例(43%,95%CI 34 - 51%),可能使研究药物代谢显著降低的有17例(14%,95%CI 8 - 20%)。研究药物可能使CM代谢轻度降低的有39例(32%,95%CI 24 - 40%),可能使CM代谢显著降低的有28例(23%,95%CI 15 - 30%)。在67例因停用CM以最终能够参加临床试验的患者中,36例(54%,95%CI 41 - 66%)进行了CM替代。总体而言,2例患者(0.7%,95%CI 0.1 - 2.6%)因无法停用或替代CM而不符合方案入组条件。
本研究强调了参加I期临床试验的癌症患者中合并用药的高发生率。通过仔细替代和停用CM,大多数患者确实符合试验入组标准。停用CM最常见的原因是方案禁止。最常停用的药物是草药、质子泵抑制剂、选择性5-羟色胺再摄取抑制剂类抗抑郁药和非甾体抗炎药。