Longo Matthew R, Haggard Patrick
Department of Psychological Sciences, Birkbeck, University of London, London WC1E 7HX, United Kingdom.
Acta Psychol (Amst). 2012 Oct;141(2):164-8. doi: 10.1016/j.actpsy.2012.07.015. Epub 2012 Sep 8.
Recent studies have revealed that somatosensory processing relies on a class of implicit body representations showing large distortions of size and shape. The relation between these representations and the conscious body image remains unclear. Dissociations have been reported in the clinical literature on eating disorders between different body image measures, with larger and more consistent distortions found with depictive measures, in which participants compare their body to a visual depiction of a body, than metric measures, in which participants compare their body to some non-body standard. Here, we compared implicit body representations underlying position sense to the body image measured with both depictive and metric methods. The body image was measured using both a depictive method (template matching) in which participants judged whether their hand was wider or more slender than a shown hand picture, and a metric method (line length) in which participants judged whether different parts of their hand were shorter or longer than a presented line. Consistent with previous findings, characteristic distortions were found for the implicit body representation underlying position sense. These distortions were also found in attenuated form for metric - but not depictive - body image measures. While replicating the basic dissociation between implicit body representations and the conscious body image, these results demonstrate that this dissociation is not absolute and specific tasks may utilise both to varying degrees depending on task demands. Metric measures may not be pure measures of body image, but some combination of visual and somatosensory body representations.
最近的研究表明,体感处理依赖于一类隐含的身体表征,这类表征显示出大小和形状的大幅扭曲。这些表征与有意识的身体意象之间的关系仍不明确。在饮食失调的临床文献中,不同身体意象测量方法之间存在分离现象,与参与者将自己的身体与身体的视觉描绘进行比较的描绘性测量方法相比,参与者将自己的身体与一些非身体标准进行比较的度量性测量方法发现了更大且更一致的扭曲。在这里,我们将位置感所基于的隐含身体表征与用描绘性和度量性方法测量的身体意象进行了比较。身体意象的测量使用了两种方法,一种是描绘性方法(模板匹配),参与者判断自己的手比展示的手部图片更宽还是更窄;另一种是度量性方法(线长),参与者判断自己手部的不同部位比呈现的线短还是长。与先前的研究结果一致,在位置感所基于的隐含身体表征中发现了特征性扭曲。在度量性身体意象测量中也发现了这种扭曲的减弱形式,但在描绘性身体意象测量中未发现。这些结果在重现隐含身体表征与有意识身体意象之间基本分离的同时,表明这种分离并非绝对的,特定任务可能会根据任务需求不同程度地同时利用两者。度量性测量可能不是身体意象的纯粹测量方法,而是视觉和体感身体表征的某种组合。