Digestive Physiopathology Unit, Gabriele d'Annunzio University, Pescara Civic Hospital, 65124 Pescara, Italy.
World J Gastroenterol. 2012 Aug 28;18(32):4386-90. doi: 10.3748/wjg.v18.i32.4386.
To compare triple therapy vs quadruple therapy for 10 d as first-line treatment of Helicobacter pylori (H. pylori) infection.
Consecutive H. pylori positive patients never treated in the past for this infection were randomly treated with triple therapy of pantoprazole (PAN) 20 mg bid, amoxicillin (AMO) 1 g bid and moxifloxacin (MOX) 400 mg bid for 10 d (PAM) or with quadruple therapy of PAN 20 mg bid, AMO 1 g bid, MOX 400 mg bid and bismuth subcitrate 240 mg bid for 10 d (PAMB). All patients were found positive at 13 C-Urea breath test (UBT) performed within ten days prior to the start of the study. A successful outcome was confirmed with an UBT performed 8 wk after the end of treatment. χ(2) analysis was used for statistical comparison. Per protocol (PP) and intention-to-treat (ITT) values were also calculated.
Fifty-seven patients were enrolled in the PAM group and 50 in the PAMB group. One patient in each group did not return for further assessment. Eradication was higher in the PAMB group (negative: 46 and positive: 3) vs the PAM group (negative: 44 and positive: 12). The H. pylori eradication rate was statistically significantly higher in the PAMB group vs the PAM group, both with the PP and ITT analyses (PP: PAMB 93.8%, PAM 78.5%, P < 0.02; ITT: PAMB 92%, PAM 77.1 %, P <0.03).
The addition of bismuth subcitrate can be considered a valuable adjuvant to triple therapy in those areas where H. pylori shows a high resistance to fluoroquinolones.
比较 10 天三联疗法与四联疗法作为幽门螺杆菌(H. pylori)感染的一线治疗。
连续的 H. pylori 阳性患者,既往从未对此感染进行过治疗,随机接受三联疗法治疗,即泮托拉唑(PAN)20mg,bid;阿莫西林(AMO)1g,bid;莫西沙星(MOX)400mg,bid,共 10 天(PAM),或四联疗法治疗,即泮托拉唑(PAN)20mg,bid;阿莫西林(AMO)1g,bid;莫西沙星(MOX)400mg,bid;枸橼酸铋钾 240mg,bid,共 10 天(PAMB)。所有患者在研究开始前 10 天内均行 13 C-尿素呼气试验(UBT),结果阳性。治疗结束后 8 周行 UBT 确认治疗成功。采用 χ(2)检验进行统计学比较。还计算了符合方案(PP)和意向治疗(ITT)值。
57 例患者纳入 PAM 组,50 例患者纳入 PAMB 组。每组各有 1 例患者未返回进行进一步评估。PAMB 组的根除率更高(阴性:46 例,阳性:3 例),PAM 组(阴性:44 例,阳性:12 例)。PAMB 组与 PAM 组的 H. pylori 根除率均有统计学显著差异,PP 和 ITT 分析均如此(PP:PAMB 组 93.8%,PAM 组 78.5%,P < 0.02;ITT:PAMB 组 92%,PAM 组 77.1%,P < 0.03)。
在氟喹诺酮类药物耐药率较高的地区,枸橼酸铋钾的添加可被视为三联疗法的有效辅助治疗。