Interdisciplinary Department for Social Sciences, Bar-Ilan University, Ramat-Gan, Israel.
Int Psychogeriatr. 2013 Jan;25(1):6-15. doi: 10.1017/S1041610212001548. Epub 2012 Sep 13.
While it is generally agreed that traditional societies are more favorable toward their elders, research findings have been inconsistent. Accordingly, this study presents a cultural comparison between Jews and Arabs in Israel in attitudes toward older adults and personal views regarding one's own aging. It was assumed that Arabs would rate their culture as more tolerant toward older adults, would report spending more time with them, and express lower ageism and aging anxieties.
We examined 154 native Israeli citizens, 86 Jewish and 68 Muslim Arabs, who completed measures of ageism, aging anxieties, and cultural views of older adults.
Arabs rated their culture as more tolerant toward their elders, perceived older adults as significantly more contributing to society, and reported engaging in less avoiding behaviors toward them. Arabs also exhibited less general fears of growing old and concerns over one's physical appearance in old age. But it was interesting to note that Arab women reported higher scores of aging anxieties and ageist attitudes in comparison to Arab men, whereas no such differences were found among Jews.
Our findings point that the cultural importance of elders for the Arab cohort transcends beyond Westernization processes which affect the Arab society in Israel, and reflect the demanding role of Arab women as primary caregivers for the elders in the family. Limitations and implications of the study are discussed.
虽然人们普遍认为传统社会更尊重老年人,但研究结果却不一致。因此,本研究对以色列的犹太人和阿拉伯人在对待老年人的态度以及个人对自己衰老的看法方面进行了文化比较。研究假设阿拉伯人会认为自己的文化对老年人更宽容,会花更多时间陪伴他们,并且表现出较低的年龄歧视和对衰老的焦虑。
我们调查了 154 名以色列本地公民,其中 86 名是犹太人,68 名是穆斯林阿拉伯人,他们完成了年龄歧视、衰老焦虑和对老年人的文化观念的测量。
阿拉伯人认为自己的文化对老年人更宽容,认为老年人对社会有更大的贡献,并且报告说与老年人的互动行为较少。阿拉伯人也表现出对衰老的恐惧和对年老时外表的担忧较少。但有趣的是,与阿拉伯男性相比,阿拉伯女性报告的衰老焦虑和年龄歧视态度得分更高,而在犹太人中则没有发现这种差异。
我们的研究结果表明,对于阿拉伯群体来说,老年人的文化重要性超越了影响以色列阿拉伯社会的西方化进程,反映了阿拉伯妇女作为家庭中老年人主要照顾者的苛刻角色。讨论了研究的局限性和意义。