Ozaki Satoru, Kitamura Seiko, Hara Hirotaka, Shimoyama Yasuaki, Kubota Hiroshi, Abe Yukiko, Kato Kana, Inoue Masaki
Division of Pathology, Kanazawa University Hospital, Kanazawa 920-8641, Japan.
Rinsho Byori. 2012 Jul;60(7):621-6.
Of the more than 100 strains of human papillomavirus (HPV) reported to date, 13 strains are clinically significant due to the highly associated risk of cervical cancer. HPV test reagents are currently being developed to aid detection of these strains. The present study compared a novel HPV genotyping reagent using a Luminex device, which enables simultaneous quantitation of multiple targets using fluorescent beads, and gene-specific multiplex polymerase chain reaction (Luminex method) with approved in vitro diagnostics. Subjects comprised 256 patients examined at our hospital for either secondary cervical cancer testing or follow-up (mean age, 40 years; age range, 20-85 years) and specimens were obtained using a cervical brush and lavage fluid. The HPV-positive rate with the Luminex method was 51.4%(132/256), of which single and multiple strain infections constituted 65.9% (87/132) and 34.1% (45/132), respectively. Correlation testing of 50 positive and 50 negative Luminex method specimens was conducted using the HPV DNA Hybrid Capture II (HCII), revealing high overall (97%[97/100]), positive(100% [47/47]) and negative(94.3% [50/53]) concordance rates. Correlation was also high for the Clinichip HPV (Clinichip), with overall, positive and negative concordance rates of 98% (98/100), 100%(48/48) and 96.2%(50/52), respectively. Furthermore, the detection concordance rate with the Clinichip was 95.8% (46/48). Sequencing of the seven specimens showing result discrepancies (HCII, n = 3; Clinichip, n = 4) confirmed concordance with the Luminex method results in all cases, indicating the validity of the present method. The present findings suggest that the Luminex method has sufficient response capability for clinical application.
在迄今报道的100多种人乳头瘤病毒(HPV)毒株中,有13种毒株因与宫颈癌风险高度相关而具有临床意义。目前正在开发HPV检测试剂以帮助检测这些毒株。本研究比较了一种使用Luminex设备的新型HPV基因分型试剂(该设备可利用荧光微球同时对多个靶点进行定量)和经批准的体外诊断方法——基因特异性多重聚合酶链反应(Luminex法)。研究对象包括在我院接受继发性宫颈癌检测或随访的256例患者(平均年龄40岁;年龄范围20 - 85岁),使用宫颈刷和灌洗液获取标本。Luminex法检测的HPV阳性率为51.4%(132/256),其中单株感染和多株感染分别占65.9%(87/132)和34.1%(45/132)。使用HPV DNA杂交捕获II(HCII)对50份Luminex法检测为阳性和50份检测为阴性的标本进行相关性检测,结果显示总体一致性率较高(97%[97/100]),阳性一致性率为100%(47/47),阴性一致性率为94.3%(50/53)。Clinichip HPV(Clinichip)的相关性也很高,总体、阳性和阴性一致性率分别为98%(98/100)、100%(48/48)和 96.2%(50/52)。此外,与Clinichip的检测一致性率为95.8%(46/48)。对7份结果存在差异的标本(HCII,3份;Clinichip,4份)进行测序,结果证实所有病例均与Luminex法结果一致,表明本方法的有效性。本研究结果表明,Luminex法具有足够的临床应用反应能力。