Department of Forensic and Insurance Medicine, Semmelweis University, Üllői str. 93, 1091 Budapest, Hungary.
Forensic Sci Int. 2012 Nov 30;223(1-3):374.e1-8. doi: 10.1016/j.forsciint.2012.08.033. Epub 2012 Sep 10.
Several methods of estimating age on the basis of human skeletal remains are used all over the world, methods that were established using known age and sex databases or during medicolegal autopsies. Over the course of the past several decades, many tests have been carried out on various populations to confirm the applicability of these methods in age assessment. While the opinions of experts vary regarding the cranial suture closure techniques, morphology of the sternal end of the fourth rib has been proven to be more accurate as an age assessor. The purpose of this paper is to test the reliability of three age estimation methods on a Central European population. Observation of ecto- and endocranial suture closure after Meindl and Lovejoy and Acsádi and Nemeskéri (239 individuals in the case of Meindl and Lovejoy and 238 in the case of Acsádi and Nemeskéri) and morphology of the sternal ends of the third, fourth and fifth ribs in accordance with Işcan (116 individuals) was done on a Hungarian sample of known sex and age at death at autopsy procedures. According to the observations, (1) the state of ectocranial suture closure was so erratic that it was not useful in age assessment, (2) obliteration phases of the endocranial sutures yield only a rough estimation, and (3) age determination from sternal ends of the ribs was the most reliable, especially with the application of slightly expanded age intervals on the Hungarian population.
目前世界各地使用了多种基于人类骨骼遗骸的年龄估计方法,这些方法是基于已知年龄和性别的数据库或法医解剖建立的。在过去几十年中,许多测试已经在不同人群中进行,以确认这些方法在年龄评估中的适用性。虽然专家对颅骨缝闭合技术的意见不一,但第四肋骨胸骨端的形态已被证明是更准确的年龄评估指标。本文旨在测试三种年龄估计方法在中欧人群中的可靠性。通过观察 Meindl 和 Lovejoy 以及 Acsádi 和 Nemeskéri 的颅外和颅内缝闭合(Meindl 和 Lovejoy 的情况下为 239 人,Acsádi 和 Nemeskéri 的情况下为 238 人)以及 Işcan 的第三、第四和第五肋骨胸骨端形态(116 人),对在尸检程序中已知性别和死亡年龄的匈牙利样本进行了观察。根据观察结果,(1)颅外缝闭合状态非常不稳定,因此在年龄评估中没有用处,(2)颅内缝的融合阶段只能提供大致的估计,(3)从肋骨胸骨端确定年龄是最可靠的,特别是在对匈牙利人群略微扩展年龄区间的情况下。