Department of Cardiology, Stavanger University Hospital, PO Box 8100, 4068 Stavanger, Norway.
Eur J Prev Cardiol. 2012 Aug;19(4):804-12. doi: 10.1177/1741826711414624.
Indications for implantable cardioverter defibrillators (ICDs) have been widened considerably during the last decade due to the well-documented effect in the heart failure population. Exercise training (ET) has a 1A recommendation in heart failure. However, data on safety and efficacy of ET in patients with ICDs is sparse. ICD shocks are associated with reduced quality of life and increased mortality. Whether ET may have a beneficial effect in heart failure patients with an ICD is not well documented.
This review is based on a systematic search in the Pub Med database using the terms 'exercise training', 'implantable cardioverter defibrillator', and 'cardiac rehabilitation'.
Nine studies were identified, comprising 1889 patients. The average duration of exercise-based cardiac rehabilitation (CR) was 9.6 weeks. Ten ICD therapies (seven shocks) were reported in the 834 patients with ICD during ET. Between exercise sessions and during follow up 182 events were recorded including 166 shocks. Three studies (2 randomized) showed that the control group representing sedentary patients were more prone to ICD discharge than patients undergoing CR/ET. In all studies the ICD patients improved their aerobic fitness following ET. Few studies report data on the effect of ET on anxiety and depression.
Based on the current literature, ET in patients with an ICD seems to be safe and is not associated with increased risk of shocks. ET improves aerobic capacity in ICD patients, while effects on anxiety, depression and quality of life are still under debate.
由于心力衰竭人群中已有充分文献证明的疗效,植入式心脏复律除颤器(ICD)的适应证在过去十年中得到了极大的扩展。运动训练(ET)在心力衰竭中有 1A 级推荐。然而,关于 ICD 患者 ET 的安全性和疗效的数据却很少。ICD 电击会降低生活质量并增加死亡率。ET 是否对有 ICD 的心力衰竭患者有益,目前还没有很好的记录。
这篇综述是基于在 Pub Med 数据库中使用“运动训练”、“植入式心脏复律除颤器”和“心脏康复”这三个术语进行系统搜索得出的。
确定了 9 项研究,共纳入 1889 名患者。基于运动的心脏康复(CR)的平均持续时间为 9.6 周。在进行 ET 的 834 名 ICD 患者中,报告了 10 次 ICD 治疗(7 次电击)。在运动训练期间和随访期间记录了 182 次事件,包括 166 次电击。有 3 项研究(2 项为随机研究)表明,接受 CR/ET 的患者比对照组(久坐的患者)更不容易发生 ICD 放电。所有研究均表明,ICD 患者在接受 ET 后,有氧运动能力得到改善。很少有研究报告 ET 对焦虑和抑郁的影响的数据。
根据目前的文献,ICD 患者进行 ET 似乎是安全的,并且不会增加电击风险。ET 可提高 ICD 患者的有氧能力,而对焦虑、抑郁和生活质量的影响仍存在争议。