Netherlands Institute for Health Services Research, Utrecht, The Netherlands.
Int J Nurs Stud. 2013 Jan;50(1):100-8. doi: 10.1016/j.ijnurstu.2012.08.017. Epub 2012 Sep 16.
Moral distress is associated with job dissatisfaction, turnover and early retirement. Because of these negative consequences moral distress should be reduced. Little research has been done on what job factors contribute to whether or not a situation causes moral distress.
To identify individual and job characteristics associated with moral distress in nursing staff.
This is a cross sectional correlational study. Nursing staff members completed two survey questionnaires with a time-interval of 3 months. In the first survey questions were asked about job characteristics and job satisfaction. Three months afterwards the respondents answered questions on moral distress.
365 nursing staff members employed in nursing homes, homes for the elderly, home care and acute care hospitals completed both questionnaires.
High moral distress levels were related to lower job satisfaction. Moral distress is higher when nurses perceive less time available to give care to patients. If satisfaction with the consultation possibilities within the team is low and when an instrumental leadership style exists, nursing staff members are also more likely to experience moral distress. Nursing staff members working 30-40h per week experience less moral distress than colleagues working fewer hours per week. Multivariate analyses showed no relations with other individual characteristics measured.
Job characteristics that contribute to moral distress should be an issue for managers because it is related to job satisfaction. Interventions to reduce moral distress should target at organisational issues. The way a team is supported can raise or decrease moral distress levels.
道德困境与工作不满、离职和提前退休有关。由于这些负面影响,应该减少道德困境。很少有研究关注哪些工作因素会导致道德困境。
确定与护理人员道德困境相关的个体和工作特征。
这是一项横断面相关性研究。护理人员在 3 个月的时间间隔内完成了两份调查问卷。在第一次调查中,询问了工作特征和工作满意度的问题。三个月后,受访者回答了有关道德困境的问题。
365 名在养老院、老年人家中、家庭护理和急性护理医院工作的护理人员完成了两份问卷。
高道德困境水平与较低的工作满意度相关。当护士认为可用于照顾患者的时间较少时,道德困境就会更高。如果对团队内咨询可能性的满意度较低,并且存在工具性领导风格,护理人员也更有可能经历道德困境。每周工作 30-40 小时的护理人员比每周工作时间较少的同事经历的道德困境更少。多变量分析显示与测量的其他个体特征无关。
导致道德困境的工作特征应该是管理者关注的问题,因为它与工作满意度有关。减少道德困境的干预措施应针对组织问题。团队的支持方式可以提高或降低道德困境水平。