Kylee Trevillion, BSc (Hons), King's College London, London, UK.
J Am Psychiatr Nurses Assoc. 2012 Nov-Dec;18(6):326-36. doi: 10.1177/1078390312459747. Epub 2012 Sep 17.
Despite numerous policies advocating for routine enquiry of abuse by mental health professionals, it is not known if such enquiry is acceptable to service users and clinicians. Furthermore, limited evidence exists on clinicians' response to domestic violence. This study aims to explore the acceptability of routine enquiry and experiences of responding to domestic violence from service user and professional perspectives.
A qualitative study design was used to conduct individual interviews with a purposive sample of community mental health service users (n = 24) and professionals (n = 25). Thematic analysis was employed to establish superordinate and subordinate themes, which were transformed into conceptual maps.
All service users considered routine enquiry about domestic violence in mental health settings to be acceptable but a small minority of professionals did not. Service users described positive experiences of help seeking, including receiving acknowledgement for the abuse and support for their multiple needs, and negative experiences, including nonvalidating responses from clinicians following disclosure, discrimination, and an absence of support from services. Main themes for professionals included difficulties in assessment and management of domestic violence, reporting requirements, and unclear referral pathways.
To respond to the needs of mental health service users experiencing domestic violence, services need to articulate a clear care and referral pathway.
尽管有许多政策主张精神卫生专业人员例行询问虐待情况,但尚不清楚这种询问是否能被服务使用者和临床医生接受。此外,关于临床医生对家庭暴力的反应的证据有限。本研究旨在从服务使用者和专业人员的角度探讨例行询问的可接受性以及应对家庭暴力的经验。
采用定性研究设计,对社区心理健康服务使用者(n=24)和专业人员(n=25)进行了有针对性的个人访谈。采用主题分析确定了上位和下位主题,并将其转化为概念图。
所有服务使用者都认为在心理健康环境中例行询问家庭暴力是可以接受的,但少数专业人员不这么认为。服务使用者描述了积极的求助经历,包括对虐待的承认和对他们多种需求的支持,以及负面经历,包括临床医生在披露后不认可、歧视和服务缺乏支持。专业人员的主要主题包括家庭暴力的评估和管理困难、报告要求和不明确的转介途径。
为了满足经历家庭暴力的心理健康服务使用者的需求,服务需要明确清晰的护理和转介途径。