Mathieu-Nolf M, Furon D
Centre Anti-Poisons, Hospital Calmette, CHU de Lille, France.
Vet Hum Toxicol. 1990 Feb;32(1):32-4.
There is great diversity among Poison Centers (PC) concerning the origin of their calls. If some PC answer only calls from hospitals or general practitioners, other like the Lille PC also answer calls from the public. To evaluate the value of this for the general public, we reviewed all the cases of poisoned children hospitalized at the Lille University Hospital during a 3-month period. All had not previously called the PC for advice. In the 80 relevant cases, the advice of the PC physicians would have been no treatment in 20 cases (25%), a call to a general practitioner in 13 cases (16%), and hospitalization in 47 cases (59%). A great homogeneity existed among the PC physicians' answers, with only 2 discrepancies in the no-hospitalization group. Analysis of data showed that there were significantly more symptomatic intoxications in the hospitalization group than in the no-hospitalization group. No patient who would have been advised not to be hospitalized presented any life threatening or severe symptoms during their hospital stay. We conclude that answering the calls from the general public is feasible and that the advice of a trained PC physician is practical and appropriate. We calculate that in answering calls from the general public the Lille PC saved 4,760,295 FF (US $761,650) in 1987.
各中毒控制中心(PC)接到的电话来源差异很大。有些中毒控制中心只接听来自医院或全科医生的电话,而其他的,比如里尔中毒控制中心,也接听公众的电话。为了评估这对公众的价值,我们回顾了在三个月期间入住里尔大学医院的所有中毒儿童病例。所有这些儿童此前均未致电中毒控制中心寻求建议。在80例相关病例中,中毒控制中心医生的建议是:20例(25%)无需治疗,13例(16%)致电全科医生,47例(59%)住院治疗。中毒控制中心医生的回答高度一致,在无需住院治疗的组中只有2例存在差异。数据分析表明,住院组的有症状中毒病例明显多于非住院组。在建议不住院的患者中,没有一人在住院期间出现任何危及生命或严重的症状。我们得出结论,接听公众的电话是可行的,而且训练有素的中毒控制中心医生的建议是切实可行且恰当的。我们计算得出,1987年里尔中毒控制中心接听公众电话节省了4760295法郎(761650美元)。