Analysis of compound weighing precision in drug discovery.

Early drug discovery laboratories often call for the precise weighing of 1- to 5-mg solids into 4- to 5-g glass vials. For the balance used in this study (Mettler Toledo XP205), the manufacturer rates its accuracy at ±0.01 mg over the working range of 1 mg to 220 g and its precision or repeatability at 0.015 mg for 10-g weights. The manufacturer ratings were confirmed using standard steel weights, but these calibrators do not well represent the weighing precision of drug compound. For example, when pre-taring a 4- to 5-g vial on the balance and then weighing 1- to 5-mg calibration weights, although no bias was observed, precision dropped appreciably. When measuring solid sample in the range of 1 to 5 mg, deviation of the measured weight from the actual (true) weight was even worse, in the range of ±20% to 50%. Balance settings and environmental factors exert a strong influence on weighing precision. Although most environmental factors, such as air draughts, temperature, vibrations, and levelness, can be optimized to the extent practical in laboratory settings, problems due to static electricity are often overlooked. By controlling static electricity, we demonstrate how we optimized the process to where measurements were within ±10% of actual weight when weighing solid sample in the range of 2 to 5 mg and ±20% when weighing 1 mg into a 4- to 5-g vial. Our weighing process and method to calculate actual weight are given in detail.