The risk of failure after primary orchidopexy: an 18 year review.

OBJECTIVE

To review the primary orchidopexy failure rate and outcome of repeat orchidopexy in a tertiary paediatric surgical centre and identify risk factors.

METHODS

A prospectively collected and validated audits system was used to identify all boys having a repeat orchidopexy from August 1990 to December 2008 (18 years).

RESULTS

In total, 1538 boys underwent orchidopexy with 1886 testicles operated on. Of these 348 (22.6%) patients had bilateral cryptorchidism. A need for repeat orchidopexy was identified in 31 boys resulting in a primary failure rate of 1.6% over the 18 years. Unilateral orchidopexy as the primary operation had a 1.5% failure rate. The failure rate for bilateral cryptorchidism was 1.87% per testicle rising to 1.93% per testicle when the primary operation was synchronous bilateral orchidopexy. Orchidopexy failure occurred in 9 patients (1.97%) who were under 24 months, 15 (2.67%) who were between 24 and 72 months and 7 (0.8%) over 72 months at time of first operation.

CONCLUSION

Possible risk factors for primary orchidopexy failure are bilateral operation and older age at time of operation. Failure in achieving a satisfactory scrotal position (and testicular loss) following orchidopexy has been postulated as a potential surgical standard for revalidation of paediatric surgeons. This study adds important contemporary data to inform that process.