Pharmacy, Hôpital Brabois-Adultes, CHU de Nancy, allée du Morvan, 54511 Vandœuvre-lès-Nancy, France.
Med Mal Infect. 2012 Dec;42(12):608-14. doi: 10.1016/j.medmal.2012.08.004. Epub 2012 Oct 1.
The objective of our study was to assess the good use of fluoroquinolone (FQ) in a French teaching hospital by a two round relevance review before and after proposal for better use of FQ prescriptions.
The relevance of FQ prescription according to regional guidelines was assessed using a standard card filled out retrospectively by physicians in the 3 previous months, in volunteer hospital wards. Then, two experts checked the relevance of prescriptions according to the regional antibiotherapy guidelines, a book called "Antibioguide", and determined a therapeutic index of adequacy for each card. The first survey (R1) took place in January 2008. The second survey (R2) took place in June 2009 to evaluate the impact of corrective measures, adopted at a meeting of the regional antibiotics commission in January 2009.
Physicians in 18 wards completed 475 cards in R1 and physicians in 16 wards completed 263 in R2. The inappropriateness of FQ indication was significantly improved by 57% (P<0.001) between the two rounds and the rate of adequate cards was 33% in R1 and 55% in R2, giving an improvement of 66% (P<0.001).
The improvement of FQ prescriptions and observance of guidelines demonstrate the importance of assessing the state of things before introducing corrective actions. "Antibioguide" was updated at the end of this study.
我们的研究目的是通过两轮相关性审查,评估法国一所教学医院氟喹诺酮(FQ)的合理使用情况,一轮审查在提出更好的 FQ 处方使用建议之前进行,另一轮审查在建议之后进行。
通过医生在过去 3 个月内填写的标准卡,回顾性评估 FQ 处方的相关性,该标准卡适用于地区指南。然后,两名专家根据地区抗生素治疗指南、一本名为“Antibioguide”的书籍,以及每张卡片的治疗适宜指数,检查处方的相关性。第一次调查(R1)于 2008 年 1 月进行。第二次调查(R2)于 2009 年 6 月进行,以评估 2009 年 1 月地区抗生素委员会会议上采取的纠正措施的影响。
18 个病房的医生完成了 475 张 R1 卡片,16 个病房的医生完成了 263 张 R2 卡片。两轮调查之间,FQ 指征的不适当性显著改善了 57%(P<0.001),适当卡片的比例从 R1 的 33%提高到 R2 的 55%,提高了 66%(P<0.001)。
FQ 处方的改进和指南的遵守证明了在引入纠正措施之前评估现状的重要性。“Antibioguide”在本研究结束时进行了更新。