Raymond S, Bourdelin M, Becker M, Henon T, Patry I, Leroy J, Limat S
Pôle pharmaceutique, hôpital Jean-Minjoz, CHU de Besançon, 3, boulevard Alexandre-Fleming, 25030 Besançon, France.
Med Mal Infect. 2011 Jun;41(6):330-5. doi: 10.1016/j.medmal.2011.02.002. Epub 2011 Mar 22.
Improving the use of antimicrobial drugs is a national objective. To this end an evaluation of clinical practice was implemented on prescribed antibiotics in elderly patients, in the Besançon Teaching Hospital.
In 2005, a clinical audit compared the adequacy of antibiotic prescriptions to national guidelines in 37 patients. An improvement plan was implemented, including the drafting of local guidelines (adapted national guidelines) "Antibiotic prescription in elderly patients" by a multidisciplinary team. The Antibiotics Committee approved it. A retrospective study compared antibiotic prescription of 62 patients to these guidelines. The methodology was based on Gyssen's algorithm. The assessment criteria were: relevance of the indication, absence of a better alternative, respect of recommended dose, duration, and timing.
The rate of overall conformity was 26% in 2005, 57% in 2007. Antibiotic choice was adequate in 61% of cases in 2005, 78% in 2007. In 63% of cases, a more efficient alternative was advised in 2005, 10% of cases in 2007. Treatment duration, dose, and timing were adequate in 54 - 92 - 96% in 2005 respectively and 86 - 92 - 100% of cases in 2007. Ciprofloxacin was prescribed in first line for 42% of urinary infections in 2005, 0% in 2007.
This approach improved antibiotic prescriptions because of better guideline observance by physicians. The main improvement concerned fluoroquinolones. It should be continued to confirm antibiotic good use and protect our hospital bacterial ecology.
改善抗菌药物的使用是一项国家目标。为此,在贝桑松教学医院对老年患者开具的抗生素进行了临床实践评估。
2005年,一项临床审计比较了37例患者抗生素处方与国家指南的相符性。实施了一项改进计划,包括由多学科团队起草当地指南(改编后的国家指南)“老年患者抗生素处方”。抗生素委员会批准了该指南。一项回顾性研究将62例患者的抗生素处方与这些指南进行了比较。该方法基于吉森算法。评估标准为:适应证的相关性、无更好替代药物、遵守推荐剂量、疗程和用药时间。
2005年总体符合率为26%,2007年为57%。2005年61%的病例抗生素选择恰当,2007年为78%。2005年63%的病例建议使用更有效的替代药物,2007年为10%。2005年治疗疗程、剂量和用药时间分别有54% - 92% - 96%的病例恰当,2007年为86% - 92% - 100%。2005年42%的泌尿系统感染一线使用环丙沙星,2007年为0%。
由于医生更好地遵守指南,这种方法改善了抗生素处方。主要的改进涉及氟喹诺酮类药物。应继续保持以确保持续合理使用抗生素并保护我院的细菌生态。