Department of Psychiatry, ESIC Model Hospital, Ahmedabad, India.
Asian J Psychiatr. 2011 Sep;4(3):210-3. doi: 10.1016/j.ajp.2011.07.001. Epub 2011 Sep 8.
Of late, there has been an increase in the number of psychiatrists shown in Hindi movies. There is dearth of systematic research that focuses specifically upon the depiction of psychiatrists in Hindi cinema.
To explore the portrayal of psychiatrists in recent Hindi cinema.
Twenty-six Hindi movies released between January 2001 and March 2010 portraying 33 'psychiatrist' characters in a main or a secondary (but significant) role, were reviewed and data related to the personal attributes and professional conduct of the movie psychiatrists was collected.
The portrayal of psychiatrists in Hindi movies released in the first decade of the 21st century is unflattering. Hindi movies depicted psychiatrists as most likely to be male, middle-aged, and friendly in their attitude towards the patients. 42.4% of them were clinically incompetent, and only 30.3% could make an accurate diagnosis. 39.4% of them breached professional ethics. Eight (24. 2%) transgressed non-sexual boundaries, whereas five (15.2%) violated both sexual and non-sexual boundaries. The most common clinical/treatment setting was outpatient (53.8%), and pharmacotherapy was the most common treatment modality used. Treatment outcome was depicted positive in only 23.1% of the movies analyzed.
最近,在印地语电影中出现的精神科医生数量有所增加。但是,缺乏专门针对印地语电影中精神科医生描绘的系统研究。
探索近期印地语电影中精神科医生的描绘。
回顾了 2001 年 1 月至 2010 年 3 月期间上映的 26 部描绘 33 个主要或次要(但重要)角色的“精神科医生”的印地语电影,并收集了与电影中精神科医生的个人属性和专业行为相关的数据。
21 世纪第一个十年上映的印地语电影中对精神科医生的描绘并不讨人喜欢。印地语电影将精神科医生描绘为最有可能是男性、中年且对患者态度友好。其中 42.4%的人临床能力不足,只有 30.3%的人能够做出准确的诊断。其中 39.4%的人违反了职业道德。有 8 人(24.2%)违反了非性界限,而 5 人(15.2%)同时违反了性和非性界限。最常见的临床/治疗环境是门诊(53.8%),最常见的治疗方式是药物治疗。在分析的电影中,仅有 23.1%的电影中描绘了积极的治疗结果。