The element effect revisited: factors determining leaving group ability in activated nucleophilic aromatic substitution reactions.

The "element effect" in nucleophilic aromatic substitution reactions (S(N)Ar) is characterized by the leaving group order, F > NO(2) > Cl ≈ Br > I, in activated aryl halides. Multiple causes for this result have been proposed. Experimental evidence shows that the element effect order in the reaction of piperidine with 2,4-dinitrophenyl halides in methanol is governed by the differences in enthalpies of activation. Computational studies of the reaction of piperidine and dimethylamine with the same aryl halides using the polarizable continuum model (PCM) for solvation indicate that polar, polarizability, solvation, and negative hyperconjugative effects are all of some importance in producing the element effect in methanol. In addition, a reversal of polarity of the C-X bond from reactant to transition state in the case of ArCl and ArBr compared to ArF also contributes to their differences in reactivity. The polarity reversal and hyperconjugative influences have received little or no attention in the past. Nor has differential solvation of the different transition states been strongly emphasized. An anionic nucleophile, thiolate, gives very early transition states and negative activation enthalpies with activated aryl halides. The element effect is not established for these reactions. We suggest that the leaving group order in the gas phase will be dependent on the exact combination of nucleophile, leaving group, and substrate framework. The geometry of the S(N)Ar transition state permits useful, qualitative conceptual distinctions to be made between this reaction and other modes of nucleophilic attack.