BC Centre for Excellence in HIV/AIDS, Vancouver, Canada.
Int J Drug Policy. 2012 Nov;23(6):436-41. doi: 10.1016/j.drugpo.2012.05.003. Epub 2012 Oct 22.
British Columbia (BC), Canada, is home to a large illegal cannabis industry that is known to contribute to substantial organized crime concerns. Although debates have emerged regarding the potential benefits of a legally regulated market to address a range of drug policy-related social problems, the value of the local (i.e., domestically consumed) cannabis market has not been characterized.
Monte Carlo simulation methods were used to generate a median value and 95% credibility interval for retail expenditure estimates of the domestic cannabis market in BC. Model parameter estimates were obtained for the number of cannabis users, the frequency of cannabis use, the quantity of cannabis used, and the price of cannabis from government surveillance data and studies of BC cannabis users.
The median annual estimated retail expenditure on cannabis by British Columbians was $407 million (95% Credibility Interval [CI]: $169-948 million). Daily users accounted for the bulk of the cannabis revenue, with a median estimated expenditure of approximately $357 million (95% CI: $149-845 million), followed by weekly users ($44 million, 95% CI: $18-90 million), and monthly users ($6 million, 95% CI: $3-12 million). When under-reporting of cannabis use was adjusted for, the estimated retail expenditure ranged from $443 million (95% CI: $185-1 billion) to $564 million (95% CI: $236-1.3 billion).
Based on local consumption patterns, conservative estimates suggest that BC's domestic illegal cannabis trade is worth hundreds of millions of dollars annually. Given the value of this market and the failure and harms of law enforcement efforts to control the cannabis market, policymakers should consider regulatory alternatives.
加拿大不列颠哥伦比亚省(BC)拥有庞大的非法大麻产业,众所周知,该产业对大量有组织犯罪活动构成严重关切。尽管围绕合法监管市场是否可能带来一系列与毒品政策相关的社会问题的潜在好处展开了辩论,但尚未对当地(即国内消费)大麻市场的价值进行描述。
使用蒙特卡罗模拟方法生成不列颠哥伦比亚省国内大麻市场零售支出估计值的中位数及其 95%可信区间。从政府监测数据和对不列颠哥伦比亚省大麻使用者的研究中,获得了大麻使用者人数、大麻使用频率、大麻使用量和大麻价格等模型参数估计值。
不列颠哥伦比亚省居民每年估计在大麻上的零售支出中位数为 4.07 亿美元(95%可信区间[CI]:1.69-9.48 亿美元)。每日使用者占大麻收入的大部分,估计支出中位数约为 3.57 亿美元(95% CI:1.49-8.45 亿美元),其次是每周使用者(4400 万美元,95% CI:1800-9000 万美元)和每月使用者(600 万美元,95% CI:300-1200 万美元)。当调整大麻使用报告不足的情况后,估计的零售支出范围从 4.43 亿美元(95% CI:1.85-10 亿美元)到 5.64 亿美元(95% CI:2.36-13 亿美元)。
根据当地消费模式,保守估计表明,BC 的国内非法大麻贸易每年价值数亿美元。鉴于该市场的价值以及执法努力控制大麻市场的失败和危害,政策制定者应考虑监管替代方案。