Department of Ecology and Evolutionary Biology, Princeton University, Princeton, NJ 08540, USA.
Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2012 Nov 6;109(45):18338-43. doi: 10.1073/pnas.1213767109. Epub 2012 Oct 22.
The global financial crisis has precipitated an increasing appreciation of the need for a systemic perspective toward financial stability. For example: What role do large banks play in systemic risk? How should capital adequacy standards recognize this role? How is stability shaped by concentration and diversification in the financial system? We explore these questions using a deliberately simplified, dynamic model of a banking system that combines three different channels for direct transmission of contagion from one bank to another: liquidity hoarding, asset price contagion, and the propagation of defaults via counterparty credit risk. Importantly, we also introduce a mechanism for capturing how swings in "confidence" in the system may contribute to instability. Our results highlight that the importance of relatively large, well-connected banks in system stability scales more than proportionately with their size: the impact of their collapse arises not only from their connectivity, but also from their effect on confidence in the system. Imposing tougher capital requirements on larger banks than smaller ones can thus enhance the resilience of the system. Moreover, these effects are more pronounced in more concentrated systems, and continue to apply, even when allowing for potential diversification benefits that may be realized by larger banks. We discuss some tentative implications for policy, as well as conceptual analogies in ecosystem stability and in the control of infectious diseases.
全球金融危机促使人们越来越认识到,需要从系统的角度来考虑金融稳定性。例如:大型银行在系统性风险中扮演什么角色?资本充足率标准应如何认识到这一角色?金融体系的集中化和多样化如何影响稳定性?我们使用一个经过精心简化的银行系统动态模型来探讨这些问题,该模型结合了三种不同的银行间直接传染渠道:流动性囤积、资产价格传染以及通过对手方信用风险传播违约。重要的是,我们还引入了一种机制,以捕捉系统中“信心”的波动如何可能导致不稳定。我们的结果强调,相对较大且联系紧密的银行在系统稳定性中的重要性与其规模不成比例地增加:它们的崩溃不仅源于其关联性,还源于它们对系统信心的影响。对较大的银行实施比较小的银行更严格的资本要求可以增强系统的弹性。此外,在更集中的系统中,这些影响更为明显,即使考虑到大型银行可能实现的潜在多样化收益,这些影响仍然适用。我们讨论了一些政策上的初步影响,以及在生态系统稳定性和传染病控制方面的概念类比。