ENT Deptartment, Lister Hospital, Stevenage, UK.
Acta Otorhinolaryngol Ital. 2012 Aug;32(4):213-21.
Haemangiomas represent the most common benign tumours in infancy, affecting 1-2% of newborns. The present meta-analysis aimed to critically review the current evidence on the efficacy of propranolol in the management of airway haemangiomas, and explore potential adverse events and treatment failures. A literature review was performed in Medline and other available database sources, along with critical analysis of pooled data. Seventeen studies were included in the analysis. No study represented Level I evidence. The total number of treated patients was 61; 14 patients received propranolol as single-treatment. The comparative effectiveness of propranolol vs. systemic steroids was documented in 35 children, and showed superior outcome in the vast majority (94%, p < 0.001). The mean obstruction before propranolol administration was 72%, and after intervention was 20% (p < 0.001). The mean referral-age for children with airway haemangiomas was 2.4 months, the mean starting-age of propranolol treatment was 5.1 months and the mean follow-up period was 8.4 months. Four children failed to respond (6.5%), and in seven the haemangioma relapsed after discontinuation of treatment (11.5%). The results of the present study suggest that propranolol can be recommended for the treatment of airway haemangiomas, as it was found to be effective and outperformed the previously-considered gold standard treatment methods, with fewer side-effects. Immediate treatment with propranolol should be initiated once a diagnosis of symptomatic airway haemangioma is confirmed, and cardiovascular assessment has been performed. Children should remain on propranolol until the haemangioma enters the phase of involution. Active parental monitoring is essential to ensure treatment safety.
血管瘤是婴儿期最常见的良性肿瘤,影响 1-2%的新生儿。本荟萃分析旨在批判性地回顾普萘洛尔治疗气道血管瘤的疗效的现有证据,并探讨潜在的不良事件和治疗失败。在 Medline 和其他可用的数据库来源中进行了文献回顾,并对汇总数据进行了批判性分析。共有 17 项研究纳入分析。没有研究代表 I 级证据。接受治疗的患者总数为 61 例;14 例患者接受普萘洛尔单一治疗。在 35 名儿童中记录了普萘洛尔与全身类固醇的比较疗效,结果显示绝大多数(94%,p < 0.001)疗效更好。普萘洛尔给药前的平均阻塞率为 72%,干预后为 20%(p < 0.001)。气道血管瘤患儿的平均转诊年龄为 2.4 个月,普萘洛尔治疗的平均起始年龄为 5.1 个月,平均随访时间为 8.4 个月。有 4 名儿童治疗失败(6.5%),7 名儿童在停止治疗后血管瘤复发(11.5%)。本研究结果表明,普萘洛尔可推荐用于治疗气道血管瘤,因为它被发现有效,并且优于先前被认为是黄金标准的治疗方法,且副作用更少。一旦确诊为有症状的气道血管瘤,并且已经进行了心血管评估,就应立即开始用普萘洛尔进行治疗。儿童应继续服用普萘洛尔,直至血管瘤进入消退期。积极的家长监测对于确保治疗安全至关重要。