Department of Human Evolution, Max Planck Institute for Evolutionary Anthropology, 04103 Leipzig, Germany.
Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2012 Nov 13;109(46):18743-8. doi: 10.1073/pnas.1212924109. Epub 2012 Oct 29.
The transition from the Middle Paleolithic (MP) to Upper Paleolithic (UP) is marked by the replacement of late Neandertals by modern humans in Europe between 50,000 and 40,000 y ago. Châtelperronian (CP) artifact assemblages found in central France and northern Spain date to this time period. So far, it is the only such assemblage type that has yielded Neandertal remains directly associated with UP style artifacts. CP assemblages also include body ornaments, otherwise virtually unknown in the Neandertal world. However, it has been argued that instead of the CP being manufactured by Neandertals, site formation processes and layer admixture resulted in the chance association of Neanderthal remains, CP assemblages, and body ornaments. Here, we report a series of accelerator mass spectrometry radiocarbon dates on ultrafiltered bone collagen extracted from 40 well-preserved bone fragments from the late Mousterian, CP, and Protoaurignacian layers at the Grotte du Renne site (at Arcy-sur-Cure, France). Our radiocarbon results are inconsistent with the admixture hypothesis. Further, we report a direct date on the Neandertal CP skeleton from Saint-Césaire (France). This date corroborates the assignment of CP assemblages to the latest Neandertals of western Europe. Importantly, our results establish that the production of body ornaments in the CP postdates the arrival of modern humans in neighboring regions of Europe. This new behavior could therefore have been the result of cultural diffusion from modern to Neandertal groups.
从中石器时代(MP)到旧石器时代晚期(UP)的转变标志着 5 万至 4 万年前欧洲晚期尼安德特人被现代人所取代。在法国中部和西班牙北部发现的 Chatelperronian(CP)人工制品组合可追溯到这个时期。到目前为止,这是唯一一种直接与 UP 风格的人工制品相关的尼安德特人遗骸的人工制品组合类型。CP 组合还包括身体装饰品,而这些在尼安德特人世界中几乎是未知的。然而,有人认为,CP 不是由尼安德特人制造的,而是由于地层形成过程和层间混合,导致尼安德特人遗骸、CP 组合和身体装饰品偶然联系在一起。在这里,我们报告了一系列来自法国 Arcy-sur-Cure 的 Renne 洞穴(Grotte du Renne)地点的 40 个保存完好的骨骼碎片的超滤液骨胶原蛋白的加速器质谱放射性碳测年数据,这些骨骼碎片来自晚期莫斯特时代、CP 和 Protoaurignacian 层。我们的放射性碳结果与混合假说不一致。此外,我们还报告了 Saint-Césaire(法国)的 CP 尼安德特人骨骼的直接日期。这一日期证实了 CP 组合与欧洲西部最晚的尼安德特人的关联。重要的是,我们的结果表明,CP 中身体装饰品的制作晚于现代人到达欧洲邻近地区的时间。因此,这种新行为可能是现代人和尼安德特人之间文化扩散的结果。