Hermelin B, O'Connor N
Medical Research Council, Institute of Education, University of London, U.K.
J Child Psychol Psychiatry. 1990 Jan;31(2):217-28. doi: 10.1111/j.1469-7610.1990.tb01563.x.
The accuracy and the artistic merit of drawings produced by graphically gifted idiot-savants and by artistically able normal children were investigated in various conditions. Drawings had to be executed when a three- or two-dimensional model of the scene to be drawn was in view, or when it had to be remembered or drawn from another viewpoint. It was found that overall accuracy was better for the normal than for the mentally handicapped subjects. In contrast, ratings for artistic merit did not differentiate the groups. It is concluded that while the accuracy of drawings may be related to intelligence, the artistic quality of the graphic production is not.
在不同条件下,对具有图形天赋的白痴学者以及有艺术才能的正常儿童所绘制图画的准确性和艺术价值进行了研究。当要绘制场景的三维或二维模型可见时,或者当必须记住该模型或从另一个视角进行绘制时,受试者都要进行绘画。结果发现,正常受试者绘制图画的总体准确性要高于智力障碍受试者。相比之下,艺术价值评分并未区分这两组受试者。研究得出结论,虽然绘画的准确性可能与智力有关,但图形作品的艺术质量并非如此。