University of Saskatchewan, Saskatoon, Saskatchewan, Canada.
Sex Abuse. 2013 Aug;25(4):396-422. doi: 10.1177/1079063212464399. Epub 2012 Nov 7.
The present study is an examination of sex offender treatment outcome in a large national cohort of Canadian Federally incarcerated sex offenders followed up an average of 11.7 years postrelease. A brief actuarial risk scale (BARS), which predicted sexual and violent recidivism, was created for the purposes of the present study to control for risk-related differences between treated and untreated offenders. In total, 732 offenders were identified as having completed (n = 625) or not attended (n = 107) a sex offender treatment program and for whom sufficient information was available to complete the scale. Controlling for risk and individual differences in follow-up time using Cox regression survival analyses and an 8-year fixed follow-up period, treated sex offenders demonstrated significantly lower rates of violent, but not sexual, recidivism. When the treated and untreated groups were stratified by risk level, significant differences were observed only among moderate or high risk offenders. Some significant group differences also emerged on indicators of recidivism severity, with treated offenders demonstrating slower times to sexual reoffense and lower scores on a quantified metric of sexual and violent recidivism severity after controlling for risk. Differences in recidivism base rates between treated and untreated offenders were also larger in magnitude for younger offenders (i.e., under age 50 at release), than for older offenders; however, interactions between age and treatment were not found. The findings are consistent with the risk principle and have possible implications regarding the dynamic nature of sexual violence risk.
本研究考察了在加拿大联邦监禁的性犯罪者中,一个大型全国队列的性犯罪者在出狱平均 11.7 年后的治疗结果。为了本研究的目的,创建了一个简短的评估风险量表(BARS),用于控制治疗和未治疗罪犯之间与风险相关的差异,该量表预测了性和暴力再犯的可能性。总共有 732 名罪犯被确定为完成(n = 625)或未参加(n = 107)性罪犯治疗计划,并为他们提供了足够的信息来完成量表。通过 Cox 回归生存分析和 8 年固定随访期,控制风险和随访时间的个体差异,接受治疗的性犯罪者表现出较低的暴力再犯率,但性再犯率没有差异。当根据风险水平对治疗组和未治疗组进行分层时,仅在中度或高度风险罪犯中观察到显著差异。在再犯严重程度的指标上也出现了一些显著的组间差异,经过风险控制后,治疗组的性犯罪复发时间较慢,性和暴力再犯严重程度的量化指标得分较低。在治疗和未治疗罪犯之间,再犯率的基础率差异在年龄较小的罪犯(即,出狱时年龄在 50 岁以下)中比年龄较大的罪犯更大;然而,未发现年龄和治疗之间的相互作用。这些发现与风险原则一致,并且可能对性暴力风险的动态性质产生影响。