Shin Jung Eun, Kim Chang-Hee, Park Hong Ju
Department of Otorhinolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery, Konkuk University Hospital, Konkuk University School of Medicine, Seoul, Korea.
Acta Otolaryngol. 2013 Feb;133(2):154-8. doi: 10.3109/00016489.2012.727469. Epub 2012 Nov 13.
Vestibular abnormality was found in 84% of patients with Meniere's disease (MD) and 66% of those with migrainous vertigo (MV), even in the interictal period. Although MV does not have proven pathology like endolymphatic hydrops of MD, MV had high vestibular abnormality, suggesting that comorbid vestibular abnormality can be a cause of vertigo and needs to be pursued.
MD and MV are common disorders causing recurrent vertigo. We determined the vestibular abnormality rates using vestibular tests with objective measurements.
Results of caloric, head-shaking nystagmus (HSN), and vibration-induced nystagmus (VIN) tests were analyzed in 45 patients with MD and 76 with MV.
The abnormal rates in MD were significantly higher than those in MV. Of 45 MD patients, 21 (47%), 32 (71%), and 24 (53%) exhibited abnormal caloric, HSN, and VIN results, respectively. Fourteen (31%) MD patients had migraine associated with vertigo, but the association was not accompanied by high rates of abnormal results in the tests. Of 76 MV patients, 19 (25%), 38 (50%), and 24 (32%) exhibited abnormal caloric, HSN, and VIN results, respectively. Overall, 84% of patients with MD and 66% with MV exhibited abnormal results on at least one test. Abnormal rates were highest in HSN, followed by VIN and the caloric test.
在梅尼埃病(MD)患者中,84%存在前庭异常;在偏头痛性眩晕(MV)患者中,66%存在前庭异常,即使在发作间期也是如此。尽管MV不像MD那样有诸如内淋巴积水的已证实病理改变,但MV有较高的前庭异常率,这表明合并的前庭异常可能是眩晕的一个原因,需要进一步研究。
MD和MV是引起反复发作性眩晕的常见疾病。我们使用客观测量的前庭测试来确定前庭异常率。
分析了45例MD患者和76例MV患者的冷热试验、摇头性眼震(HSN)和振动性眼震(VIN)测试结果。
MD患者的异常率显著高于MV患者。在45例MD患者中,分别有21例(47%)、32例(71%)和24例(53%)的冷热试验、HSN和VIN结果异常。14例(31%)MD患者伴有偏头痛性眩晕,但这种关联并未伴随着测试中高比例的异常结果。在76例MV患者中,分别有19例(25%)、38例(50%)和24例(32%)的冷热试验、HSN和VIN结果异常。总体而言,84%的MD患者和66%的MV患者至少有一项测试结果异常。异常率在HSN中最高,其次是VIN和冷热试验。