Médicos sin Fronteras España, Misión Colombia, Bogotá, Colombia.
Confl Health. 2012 Nov 21;6(1):10. doi: 10.1186/1752-1505-6-10.
Despite the fact that the Colombian armed conflict has continued for almost five decades there is still very little information on how it affects the mental health of civilians. Although it is well established in post-conflict populations that experience of organised violence has a negative impact on mental health, little research has been done on those living in active conflict zones. Médecins Sans Frontières provides mental health services in areas of active conflict in Colombia and using data from these services we aimed to establish which characteristics of the conflict are most associated with specific symptoms of mental ill health.
An analysis of clinical data from patients (N = 6,353), 16 years and over, from 2010-2011, who consulted in the Colombian departments (equivalent to states) of Nariño, Cauca, Putumayo and Caquetá. Risk factors were grouped using a hierarchical cluster analysis and the clusters were included with demographic information as predictors in logistic regressions to discern which risk factor clusters best predicted specific symptoms.
Three clear risk factor clusters emerged which were interpreted as 'direct conflict related violence', 'personal violence not directly conflict-related' and 'general hardship'. The regression analyses indicated that conflict related violence was more highly related to anxiety-related psychopathology than other risk factor groupings while non-conflict violence was more related to aggression and substance abuse, which was more common in males. Depression and suicide risk were represented equally across risk factor clusters.
As the largest study of its kind in Colombia it demonstrates a clear impact of the conflict on mental health. Among those who consulted with mental health professionals, specific conflict characteristics could predict symptom profiles. However, some of the highest risk outcomes, like depression, suicide risk and aggression, were more related to factors indirectly related to the conflict. This suggests a need to focus on the systemic affects of armed conflict and not solely on direct exposure to fighting.
尽管哥伦比亚武装冲突已持续近五十年,但有关其如何影响平民心理健康的信息仍然很少。尽管在冲突后人群中已经确定有组织暴力的经历对心理健康有负面影响,但对生活在活跃冲突地区的人群的研究却很少。无国界医生组织在哥伦比亚的活跃冲突地区提供精神卫生服务,我们利用这些服务的数据,旨在确定冲突的哪些特征与特定的心理健康问题最相关。
对 2010 年至 2011 年在纳里尼奥、考卡、普图马约和卡克塔等哥伦比亚省就诊的 16 岁及以上的 6353 名患者的临床数据进行分析。使用分层聚类分析对危险因素进行分组,将聚类结果与人口统计学信息一起作为预测因子纳入逻辑回归,以确定哪些危险因素聚类最能预测特定症状。
出现了三个明显的危险因素聚类,可解释为“直接冲突相关暴力”、“与个人暴力不直接相关”和“普遍困难”。回归分析表明,与冲突相关的暴力与焦虑相关的精神病理学的关系比其他危险因素分组更为密切,而非冲突暴力与攻击和药物滥用的关系更为密切,这种情况在男性中更为常见。抑郁和自杀风险在危险因素聚类中同样常见。
作为哥伦比亚此类研究中规模最大的一次,该研究清楚地表明了冲突对心理健康的影响。在那些寻求精神卫生专业人员咨询的人中,特定的冲突特征可以预测症状特征。然而,一些风险最高的结果,如抑郁、自杀风险和攻击,与冲突间接相关的因素更为相关。这表明有必要关注武装冲突的系统性影响,而不仅仅是直接接触战斗。