Biomechanics and Bioengineering Laboratory, UMR CNRS 7338, UTC, Compiègne, France.
Alcohol Clin Exp Res. 2013 May;37(5):811-7. doi: 10.1111/acer.12025. Epub 2012 Dec 6.
Due to the lack of cutoff values validated for specific liver diseases, the purpose of this study was to set up specific magnetic resonance elastography (MRE) cutoff values for asymptomatic liver fibrosis in alcoholic patients.
Ninety patients underwent 3 clinical exams. The liver stiffness was measured locally with the Fibroscan, and globally through cartographies of shear modulus generated with MRE. The Fibroscan method was chosen as the gold standard to classify the fibrosis. The liver score was also obtained with the Fibrometer A, and the diagnostic performance of the methods was analyzed with receiver-operating characteristic (ROC) curves and cutoff values were calculated.
Spearman correlation and area under the ROC curve revealed that MRE is a better diagnostic method than the Fibrometer A, to identify various levels of fibrosis. The results showed that the Fibrometer A was adapted for severe fibrosis. The MRE cutoff values are F1:2.20 kPa, F2:2.57 kPa, F3:3.31 kPa, and F4:4 kPa and were not influenced by the glutamic oxaloacetic transaminase level. By using the ultrasound cutoff values attributed for alcoholism, 66% of patients had a similar liver fibrosis diagnosis as the MRE cutoffs. However, both imaging techniques did not provide the same distribution for minor fibrosis.
None of the imaging techniques (Fibroscan, MRE) could replace the gold standard of the biopsy. However, due to the risk and the unnecessary procedure for the present recruited alcoholic patients, the Fibroscan method was chosen as the reference. Since MRE is currently being used as a clinical exam, the present MRE cutoffs could aid clinicians with their diagnosis of liver fibrosis for alcoholism disease.
由于缺乏针对特定肝脏疾病的截止值验证,本研究旨在为酒精性患者无症状性肝纤维化建立特定的磁共振弹性成像(MRE)截止值。
90 例患者接受了 3 项临床检查。肝脏硬度通过 Fibroscan 局部测量,并通过 MRE 生成的剪切模量图谱进行全局测量。Fibroscan 方法被选为分类纤维化的金标准。肝脏评分也通过 Fibrometer A 获得,并通过接收者操作特征(ROC)曲线分析方法的诊断性能并计算截止值。
Spearman 相关和 ROC 曲线下面积表明,MRE 是一种比 Fibrometer A 更好的诊断方法,可用于识别各种程度的纤维化。结果表明,Fibrometer A 适用于严重纤维化。MRE 的截止值为 F1:2.20 kPa、F2:2.57 kPa、F3:3.31 kPa 和 F4:4 kPa,不受谷草转氨酶水平的影响。使用归因于酒精中毒的超声截止值,66%的患者与 MRE 截止值具有相似的肝脏纤维化诊断。然而,两种影像学技术对轻度纤维化的分布并不相同。
没有一种影像学技术(Fibroscan、MRE)可以替代活检的金标准。然而,由于目前招募的酒精性患者存在风险和不必要的程序,因此选择 Fibroscan 方法作为参考。由于 MRE 目前被用作临床检查,本研究中的 MRE 截止值可以帮助临床医生诊断酒精性肝病的纤维化。