Cancer Research Division, Cancer Council NSW, 153 Dowling Street, Woolloomooloo, Sydney, NSW 2011, Australia.
BMC Health Serv Res. 2012 Dec 5;12:446. doi: 10.1186/1472-6963-12-446.
The National Cervical Screening Program in Australia currently recommends that women aged 18-69 years are screened with conventional cytology every 2 years. Publicly funded HPV vaccination was introduced in 2007, and partly as a consequence, a renewal of the screening program that includes a review of screening recommendations has recently been announced. This study aimed to provide a baseline for such a review by quantifying screening program resource utilisation and costs in 2010.
A detailed model of current cervical screening practice in Australia was constructed and we used data from the Victorian Cervical Cytology Registry to model age-specific compliance with screening and follow-up. We applied model-derived rate estimates to the 2010 Australian female population to calculate costs and numbers of colposcopies, biopsies, treatments for precancer and cervical cancers in that year, assuming that the numbers of these procedures were not yet substantially impacted by vaccination.
The total cost of the screening program in 2010 (excluding administrative program overheads) was estimated to be A$194.8M. We estimated that a total of 1.7 million primary screening smears costing $96.7M were conducted, a further 188,900 smears costing $10.9M were conducted to follow-up low grade abnormalities, 70,900 colposcopy and 34,100 histological evaluations together costing $21.2M were conducted, and about 18,900 treatments for precancerous lesions were performed (including retreatments), associated with a cost of $45.5M for treatment and post-treatment follow-up. We also estimated that $20.5M was spent on work-up and treatment for approximately 761 women diagnosed with invasive cervical cancer. Overall, an estimated $23 was spent in 2010 for each adult woman in Australia on cervical screening program-related activities.
Approximately half of the total cost of the screening program is spent on delivery of primary screening tests; but the introduction of HPV vaccination, new technologies, increasing the interval and changing the age range of screening is expected to have a substantial impact on this expenditure, as well as having some impact on follow-up and management costs. These estimates provide a benchmark for future assessment of the impact of changes to screening program recommendations to the costs of cervical screening in Australia.
澳大利亚国家宫颈筛查计划目前建议年龄在 18-69 岁的女性每 2 年进行常规细胞学筛查。2007 年开始提供公共资金 HPV 疫苗接种,因此最近宣布更新筛查计划,其中包括审查筛查建议。本研究旨在通过量化 2010 年筛查计划资源利用和成本,为该审查提供基线。
我们构建了澳大利亚当前宫颈筛查实践的详细模型,并使用维多利亚宫颈细胞学登记处的数据来对特定年龄的筛查和随访进行建模。我们将模型得出的率估计值应用于 2010 年澳大利亚女性人口,以计算当年的阴道镜检查、活检、癌前病变和宫颈癌治疗的成本和数量,假设这些程序的数量尚未因疫苗接种而受到实质性影响。
2010 年筛查计划的总成本(不包括行政计划间接费用)估计为 1.948 亿澳元。我们估计,共进行了 170 万次初级筛查涂片,耗资 9670 万澳元,进一步进行了 18.8 万次随访低级别异常的涂片,耗资 1090 万澳元,进行了 7.09 万次阴道镜检查和 3.41 万次组织学评估,总耗资 2120 万澳元,对癌前病变进行了约 1890 次治疗(包括再治疗),治疗和治疗后随访费用为 4550 万澳元。我们还估计,为大约 761 名诊断为宫颈癌的妇女进行了工作和治疗,花费了 2050 万澳元。总体而言,澳大利亚每个成年女性在宫颈筛查计划相关活动上的支出估计为 23 澳元。
筛查计划总成本的一半左右用于提供初级筛查检测;但 HPV 疫苗接种的引入、新技术的应用、延长间隔时间和改变筛查年龄范围预计将对这一支出产生重大影响,对随访和管理成本也将产生一定影响。这些估计为未来评估对澳大利亚宫颈癌筛查成本的筛查计划建议的改变对筛查计划的影响提供了基准。